Hi,

the handling of double Entries is strange. The warning, that you created an allready existing Item comes up very late.

What I did:

 * Search for "Käsebrot" -> not found
 * Create a new Item
     o enter Label: "Käsebrot"
     o enter Description: "ein Brot mit einem Belag aus Käse"
 * Add "Also known as": "Käsestulle"
 * try to add a Link to de:Käsebrot
     o get the following Error-Message: "An error occurred while trying
       to perform save and because of this, your changes could not be
       completed."
     o click Details: Edit not allowed: Site link [[dewiki:Käsebrot]]
       already used by item [[Q1795455]].


That is quite frustrating... It took seven steps until I get informed about the Error I made.

I figured out, that you only check for double Entries when you enter a Label and a Description in the currently selected language in the second Step. That check is also a check for bitwise equality. One different character in the description and you get no warning. If the desctiption and Label equals to an existing item you get the following Error-Message: "Another item (3220891) already has label "Käsebrot" and description "ein Brot mit einem Belag aus Käse" associated with language code en".

I think you should:

 * enable the search for Item-Labels
 * check the Label when creating a new Item
 * add Links to the existing Item in the error-messages


After my tests there are several Items with the Label "Käsebrot", I'm sorry for that.

LB

_______________________________________________
Wikidata-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikidata-l

Reply via email to