On 10 May 2011 17:04, Scott MacDonald <[email protected]> wrote: > I've written a little essay which I think serves to illustrate the dangers > of Wikipedia's tendency to create articles (and particularly BLPs) from a > pastiche of newspaper articles. > > See > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Otto_Middleton_%28or_why_newspapers_a > re_dubious_sources%29 > > It may amuse (or it may not) >
No it just provides further evidence you haven't really thought about the issue. Firstly lets not forget this is all in reaction to the [[Pippa Middleton]] article which is based on a wider range of sources over a longer period of time and who quite clearly exists. In any case Britain has royal watchers in much the same way it has train spotters so sourcing is not much of a concern. Secondly if you think that this is limited to BLPs and newspapers you are sadly mistaken. Jasper Maskelyne was a stage magician who served as a perfectly respectable and competent camouflage officer. After the war he had a set of ghost written memoirs published which are a mix of wild exaggerations and plain making stuff up. These stories have make it into various sources beyond newspapers: http://www.maskelynemagic.com/Resources/SEND%20IN%20THE%20CLOWNS.pdf But hey it's not limited to people. There's [[Operation Tyr]] originally a web hoax about a supposed plan by nazi germany to invade Liechtenstein. It has since made it's way into Michael Sharpe's 5th Gebirgsjäger Division: Hitler's mountain warfare specialists. The story about an dummy airfield being bombed by dummy bombs has also made it's way into an unreasonable number of sources. Covered here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Geni/WW2_sourcing_issues The difference is I'm able to document this without a WP:POINT violation. -- geni _______________________________________________ WikiEN-l mailing list [email protected] To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l
