On Thu, Nov 5, 2015 at 3:07 PM, ecemaml @ es.wikipedia wrote: > Watermarking is just an example of disparate rules that make the > international phase not equal for every country. Besides the watermarking > issue (personally I see it as the less severe issue), there should be a > common set of rules for all the countries contesting. As I've told > previously, there are pictures that do not belong to a monument at all, > countries posting more than ten pictures or providing images of elements of > movable heritage (when the remaining countries only consider immovable > heritage items). Unless the same rules apply to every country (for providing > images for the international phase) the international contest is definitely > flawed (again, it's up to each country organization to set the rules for the > national contests, however, the international one should follow a single set > of common rules).
Actually no, these are not important issues: - for the pictures that do not belong to any monument (which is probably only one, from Egypt), I am sure the international jury will have the wisdom to give it a small score; - there are no country with more than 10 pictures. France listed 3 special prizes beyond their top 10, but those 3 are clearly out of the international contest; - if there are pictures of furniture, not building interiors, also I am sure the jury will judge them correctly; - movable, immovable heritage, this is a federative contest and it was up to each country to define its list of monuments. -- nicu _______________________________________________ Wiki Loves Monuments mailing list [email protected] https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikilovesmonuments http://www.wikilovesmonuments.org
