Some of the important points from the discussions with Hindi wikipedians
are captured by
Thought of sharing that here also.
*Motivators for joining Indic Language Projects*
- Awareness mostly through search engines not through outreach or media
- It's not been about parochial (sic) notions about preserving culture
or a language or lofty ambitions about knowledge access; but about core
Wikipedia basics of building a knowledge repository
- Wanting to stay away from antagonistic, aggressive en-wp edit
- Helping the Indic language project - as the number of volunteers were
low (especially when compared to en-wp which has higher numbers of
- Very low community meet up attendance
- Not finding meet-ups as they are currently run useful as the
discussions are not engaging or relevant
- Collaboration is weak (especially on articles) - and more about process
- Doing a lot of clean up after damage done by bots
- Categorisation, copyvio clean ups
- Perform a different role on Indic projects (a lot of support work
instead of article content) as compared to their roles in en-wp (where they
edit articles on subjects of interest)
- Technical issues are not *such* a major challenge; though awareness
that technical solutions exist is low.
- Basic awareness of projects
- Lack of reliable sources online
- Media coverage on Indic language media vehicles (e.g., local language
newspapers, etc.) to build basic awareness of the very existence of Indic
language projects as well as invitation to edit
- Tie-ups with education system of various kinds (colleges, teachers,
state government bodies, etc.)
On Thu, Nov 24, 2011 at 12:24 PM, Shiju Alex <sh...@wikimedia.org> wrote:
> Dear Indic Language Wikimedia Community members,
> As part of the Indic Languages initiative of India
> I have been having detailed discussions with a wide range of Indic language
> wikipedians for the past few weeks. Yesterday I shared the summary of
> discussions with few Assamese Wikipedians which helped us to understand the
> current situation of Assamese wikipedia. Thank you for the discussions
> and ideas that emerged on the mailing list and the talk page.
> Today I'm particularly excited to share a summary of the discussions I've
> been been having with *Hindi wikipedians*. It is available here:
> I will be honest and confess that I was not sure about the level of
> engagement I would have with Hindi wikipedians because the community is
> relatively quiet in public forums. I'm really pleased to report that I was
> very pleasantly surprised by the broad-based, insightful, and constructive
> communications. Hindi community might be silent but they are active and
> full of powerful ideas. We have seen wonderful Hindi wikipedians like
> Anirudh in WCI. Even though the current community strength of Hindi
> wikipedia might not be good cosidering the huge speaker base of Hindi, I am
> sure the situation will change soon.
> Even if you are not involved in Hindi projects, I invite you to read this
> report because the points raised are applicable to all Indic languages.
> Personally, as someone who has been passionate about Indic languages for
> many years now, I found the discussions very educative and informative and
> thought-provoking. I have learnt a lot from these discussions and I hope
> you find them as useful as I have. I want to thank Hindi community for
> their time and their fantastic inputs.
> Remember most of the issues the Hindi editors raised are applicable not
> only to Hindi but for all the Indic languages. So it is important that
> other Indic language communities take lessons from it while building the
> As mentioned before, I've edited the discussions to protect
> confidentiality as well as to remove any specific personal comments.
> Inviting your active participation in these discussions (either on talk
> page or in the mailing lists).
> Warm Regards,
> Shiju Alex
Wikimediaindia-l mailing list
To unsubscribe from the list / change mailing preferences visit