There seems to be some confusion about how ResourceLoader works, which
has been leading people to make commits like r73196 and report bugs like
#25362. I would like to offer some clarification.
ResourceLoader, if you aren't already aware, is a new system in
MediaWiki 1.17 which allows developers to bundle collections of
*resources* (like JavaScript and CSS files, or localized messages) into
*modules*. Modules may represent any number of scripts, styles and
messages, which are read from the file system, the database, or
generated by software.
When a request is made for one or more modules, each resource is
packaged together and sent back to the client as a response. The way in
which these requests and responses are performed depends on whether
debug is on or off.
When debug mode is off:
* Modules are requested in batches
* Resources are combined into modules
* Modules are combined into a response
* The response is minified
When debug mode is on:
* Modules are requested individually
* Resources are combined into modules
I think it's debatable whether debug=true mode goes far enough, since it
still combines resources into modules, and I am open to contributions
that can make debug=true mode even more debugging friendly by delivering
the resources to the client as unchanged as possible. I also think it's
debatable if debug=false mode goes far enough, since things like Google
Closure Compiler have been proven to even further reduce the size of
JavaScript resources, so I am also open to contributions which can make
debug=false even more production friendly by improving front-end
performance.
The commits and bugs that I'm contending here are ones which are aiming
to dilute the optimized nature of debug=false mode, when debug=true mode
is really what they should be using or improving. These kinds of changes
and suggestions result in software that is neither optimized for
debugging or for production, making the front-end performance of the
site in production slower without making it any easier to debug than it
would have been by using debug=true.
If you are a developer, working on your localhost, you probably want to
code with...
$wgResourceLoaderDebug = true;
.. and then test that things work in debug=false mode before committing
your code. This will result in more requests but less processing, which
will be much faster when developing on localhost.
I hope this helps clarify this situation.
- Trevor
_______________________________________________
Wikitech-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikitech-l
