[Winona Online Democracy] People can buy a book "Medical Fees in the United States" 2006 by James B. Davis from Amazon for $129.95 which provides the nationwide charges for Medicine, surgery, laboratory, radiology and allied health service. Medical prices are not nuclear science but the discounting practices for non profit entities leaves much to be desired.
Non profits in the thirties were give exemption from price discrimination law suits which enable them to get special discounts from vendors and to price their items differently to insurance companies, government and individuals. For profit companies "do not" by law have that right. The Federal Trade Commission has many test cases on their web site showing actions by them to stop discriminatory pricing. The Robinson-Patman Act, the Sherman Antitrust Act prohibit for profit entities from this practice. http://www.ftc.gov/bc/bchealthcare.htm The Minnesota Attorney General and many other groups are trying to bring the non profits into the same practice as is required by law of the for profit providers. There are even some test cases which are pursuing the fact that special prices offered the Veterans Administration fall under the rules that require all "for profit providers" provide by law the same prices to any consumer. Paul Double -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Davis, William MD Sent: Monday, March 06, 2006 9:41 PM A few comments from a physician perspective. First, the "overhead" of commercial insurance varies considerably. The best companies spend 8% on administration (they pay out 92% of the premiums for health care) and the worst may have an overhead of 50%. Currently Medicare and Medicaid are running about 3% overhead. Second, physician offices and hospitals have a "price list" for every procedure they perform (office visits, shots, office surgeries, hospital ER visits, operating room costs, etc.). They are all keyed to the CPT codes (Common Procedural Terminology), a coding system developed by the AMA to permit standardization. The CPT code for an "average" office visit is 99213. This makes it possible to compare charges across communities and states for the same service. There is a detailed description of each code in a manual that is published annually to allow "coders" to determine which code to apply to a particular service. When new procedures are developed (like laparoscopic appendectomy"), a code(s) is created for the procedure so that insurance companies and the government can be billed. What happens is that big payers (Medicare, Medicaid, BCBS, etc.) can dictate to physician offices and hospitals what they will pay. It is similar to Wal-Mart telling its suppliers what they are going to pay for goods Wal-Mart will sell. It is a take it or leave it kind of deal. If we don't agree to the contract that BCBS sends us, we can't see their patients (we are "out of network"). For example, the charge for a 99213 at our office, based on our "charge master" (price list) might be $75. We currently experience about 50% "discounts" from the big payers. All patients get billed the same amount ($75 for a 99213) but what they owe will depend on the deal with their insurance company. So BCBS may have told us that they will pay only $40 and we cannot "balance bill" the rest to the patient. You can see this on your insurance EOB (explanation of benefits) that comes to you after a visit to the doctor. It gets more complicated if you have a co-pay. You may have to pay $35 to your doctor and BCBS only pays $5. The office is forced to "write off" the difference. However, if you have no insurance, you get the bill for $75 and end up paying the whole bill. This is not so bad for a $75 office visit but it can be a catastrophe for a $50,000 coronary artery bypass surgery. Some hospitals and clinics are discounting bills to patients without insurance to match the discounts they give to the insurance companies but most are not doing that. Fortunately, the number of uninsured patients is still small in Minnesota but it is a growing number as employers stop offering insurance to their employees. Sorry for this long note but it may be helpful to see what is going on from an "insiders" perspective. William Davis MD [EMAIL PROTECTED] [Winona Online Democracy] _______________________________________________ This message was posted to Winona Online Democracy All messages must be signed by the senders actual name. No commercial solicitations are allowed on this list. To manage your subscription or view the message archives, please visit http://mapnp.mnforum.org/mailman/listinfo/winona Any problems or suggestions can be directed to mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] If you want help on how to contact elected officials, go to the Contact page at http://www.winonaonlinedemocracy.org
