just caught up with this
 
i suggest a further way of looking at it is like _mistakes_ made in taxonomy where creatures look alike in some way but are not
 
no harm in noting the similarity, but if one is looking at a body of work or just the development of ideas, be it in a single process of what alan calls call and response or over a period or a group or both, then it may be a distraction
 
i had a flurry of posting some _script poems_  a few days back and inadvertently posted one elsewhere and immediately two separate people said Beckett
 
There may be connections and influence. I read or have read Beckett. But I believe that a look of the whole set of such writing of *mine, and I am aware people will be more aware of Beckett, would show that it is superficial
 
In UK at least some years ago, there was a similar reference to Pinter - anything menacing, an apparent non sequitur, an unexpected silence and everyone said Pinteresque
 
The question is, surely, what these discerned similarities tell us; often, I suggest, it is not a lot
 
L
-----Original Message-----
From: Alan Sondheim <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: [email protected] <[email protected]>
Date: Wednesday, August 10, 2005 6:52 PM
Subject: Re: you

The difference is that these are dialogic, call-and-response, not
finished, shaped, by a single author. So they're also a bit like renga...

- Alan


On Wed, 10 Aug 2005, Thomas savage wrote:

> These poems or works I see like this on this listserv and other places seem to be trying to outdo or under-do the great Samuel Beckett whose works got shorter as he got older.  It is my suggestion that they do not succeed in this regard.  I have now seen many such entries both here and sometimes in the Buffalo listserv.  It may be that noone could be further from the minds of the authors of these miniworks than Beckett but, if that is the case, I suggest they look or re-examine Beckett's late work.
>
> Dan Waber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:you
>
>
>
> ---------------------------------
> Start your day with Yahoo! - make it your home page

( URLs/DVDs/CDroms/books/etc. see http://www.asondheim.org/advert.txt -
revised 7/05 )

Reply via email to