On Sat, 28 Jan 2006 22:54:07 -0000, Andreas Boehmer [Addictive Media] <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

<tr><th>Fruits</th>...
<tr><th><span>Fruits > </span>Apple</th>...
<tr><th><span>Fruits > </span>Orange</th>...
<tr><th><span>Fruits > </span>Lemon</th>...

The problem with this solution is that it allows for only two levels of
hierarchy (parents:children = fruit:apples). But the application we are
building is more like a file/folder structure in Windows Explorer - it can have an endless number of levels. Every folder can have a
subfolder.

So you need more levels... What if you just use some simple numbering:

<tr><th><span>1 </span>Fruits</th>...
<tr><th><span>1.1 </span>Apple</th>...
<tr><th><span>1.1.1 </span>Red apple</th>...
<tr><th><span>1.1.2 </span>Green apple</th>...
<tr><th><span>1.1.2.1 </span>Extra green apple</th>...
<tr><th><span>1.1.2.2 </span>Medium green apple</th>...
<tr><th><span>1.2 </span>Orange</th>...
<tr><th><span>1.3 </span>Lemon</th>...

This should make the hierarchy pretty clean to both screenreader and
text-browser users.

There is one usability problem still: the contents of <th> elements
are centered by default in most browsers, making the table look like
this:

            1 Fruits          Add Edit Delete
           1.1 Apple          Add Edit Delete
        1.1.1 Red apple       Add Edit Delete
       1.1.2 Green apple      Add Edit Delete
   1.1.2.1 Extra green apple  Add Edit Delete
   1.1.2.2 Medium green apple Add Edit Delete
           1.2 Orange         Add Edit Delete
           1.3 Lemon          Add Edit Delete

Not very comprehensible... The solution would be to use <td> instead:

   1 Fruits                   Add Edit Delete
   1.1 Apple                  Add Edit Delete
   1.1.1 Red apple            Add Edit Delete
   1.1.2 Green apple          Add Edit Delete
   1.1.2.1 Extra green apple  Add Edit Delete
   1.1.2.2 Medium green apple Add Edit Delete
   1.2 Orange                 Add Edit Delete
   1.3 Lemon                  Add Edit Delete

Maybe it makes the table a bit harder to understand for screenreader
users, but it surely adds clarity to all the other users.

Hopefully it doesn't make me look like someone who is very into
table-based solutions :)


Rene Saarsoo
******************************************************
The discussion list for  http://webstandardsgroup.org/

See http://webstandardsgroup.org/mail/guidelines.cfm
for some hints on posting to the list & getting help
******************************************************

Reply via email to