On 16/08/2014 22:59, Michael Black wrote: Hi Mike, > It appears to me that the Omni VII does not allow you to specifically select > Mode B from the panel. Looking at the Omni VII programming manual it seems that SPLIT is always TX on Sub VFO so selecting VFO is not required. > But the programming docs do show both MODE and Split State available. > Maybe HRD isn't implementing this correctly since it's not return the > commands in the drop-down list? Indeed the SPLIT state set and query is missing in HRD and that is going to be quite limiting.
I need to enhance that HRDTransceiver class and its clients to allow for rigs that have no split control rather than just fall over as it has done for you. That is a larger task that I cannot take on right now but will look at in a week or so. > I can contact them and report the problem. OK but I doubt there will be any fast response. If you are going to ask them, then having a PTT button would also be helpful as that seems to be missing too. > > This is from the Omni VII programming manual: > Set/Get MODE > *M VFOA VFOB<CR> VFOA/B=ASCII '0' .. '6' > ?M <CR> M VFOA VFOB <CR> > Set/Get Split State > *N <d0> <CR> Range = 0..1 > ?N N <d0> <CR> > 73 Bill G4WJS. > -----Original Message----- > From: Bill Somerville [mailto:g4...@classdesign.com] > Sent: Saturday, August 16, 2014 4:43 PM > To: wsjt-devel@lists.sourceforge.net > Subject: Re: [wsjt-devel] Bug in HRD TCP > > On 16/08/2014 22:28, Michael Black wrote: > Hii Mike, >> Looks like I got a trace log after the segfault anyways. > OK, the seg fault is probably as a result of a defect which is a consequence > of not coping well with the following: > > It doesn't look like HRD has a way of selecting VFO A or VFO B nor any way > of selecting split mode on the Omni VII. > > Is it possible to select the current VFO or to select split mode from the > HRD UI fro that rig? >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:11 2014 GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\main.cpp:115)Debug: >> "WSJT-X v1.4.0 r4231-dirty by K1JT - Program startup" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:11 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\Configuration.cpp:456)Debug: >> Configuration::transceiver_online: open_if_closed: true >> Transceiver::TransceiverState(online: no Frequency {0Hz, 0Hz} UNK; SPLIT: >> unknown; PTT: off) >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:11 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HamlibTransceiver.cpp:262)Debug: >> HamlibTransceiver::do_start rig: "Kenwood TS-2000" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:11 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HamlibTransceiver.cpp:403)Debug: >> HamlibTransceiver::init_rig rig_get_vfo = 0x1 Sat Aug 16 21:15:11 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HamlibTransceiver.cpp:413)Debug: >> HamlibTransceiver::init_rig rig_get_mode = 4 bw = 2200 Sat Aug 16 >> 21:15:12 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HamlibTransceiver.cpp:423)Debug: >> HamlibTransceiver::init_rig exit Transceiver::TransceiverState(online: >> no Frequency {7076000Hz, 18109000Hz} USB; SPLIT: off; PTT: off) >> reversed = false Sat Aug 16 21:15:15 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\Configuration.cpp:1889)Debug: >> Configuration::handle_transceiver_update: Transceiver State: >> Transceiver::TransceiverState(online: yes Frequency {7076000Hz, >> 18109000Hz} USB; SPLIT: off; PTT: off) Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HamlibTransceiver.cpp:736)Debug: >> HamlibTransceiver::do_ptt: false Transceiver::TransceiverState(online: >> yes Frequency {7076000Hz, 18109000Hz} USB; SPLIT: off; PTT: off) >> reversed = false Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HamlibTransceiver.cpp:279)Debug: >> HamlibTransceiver::do_stop: state: >> Transceiver::TransceiverState(online: yes Frequency {7076000Hz, >> 18109000Hz} USB; SPLIT: off; PTT: off) reversed = false Sat Aug 16 >> 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:104)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::start >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HamlibTransceiver.cpp:262)Debug: >> HamlibTransceiver::do_start rig: "Hamlib Dummy" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HamlibTransceiver.cpp:423)Debug: >> HamlibTransceiver::init_rig exit Transceiver::TransceiverState(online: >> no Frequency {0Hz, 0Hz} UNK; SPLIT: unknown; PTT: off) reversed = >> false Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 28 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get context" ): -> "619" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 54 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get id" ): -> "Ham Radio Deluxe" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:158)Debug: "Ham Radio Deluxe" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 52 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get version" ): -> "v6.2.6.285 b285" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:159)Debug: "v6.2.6.285 b285" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 68 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radios" ): -> "619:TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:179)Debug: radios: >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:182)Debug: [ 619 ] >> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 24 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get vfo-count" ): -> "2" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:198)Debug: vfo count: 2 >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 114 Sat Aug 16 >> 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get buttons" ): -> >> "ATT,Slow,Medm,Fast,Notch,NR,A <> B,A = B,B = A" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:204)Debug: HRD Buttons: >> ("ATT", "Slow", "Medm", "Fast", "Notch", "NR", "A~<>~B", "A~=~B", >> "B~=~A") Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 74 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get dropdowns" ): -> "Mode A,Mode >> B,Wide,Med,Nar" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 54 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get dropdown-list {Mode A}" ): -> >> "AM,USB,LSB,CW,FM" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 54 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get dropdown-list {Mode B}" ): -> >> "AM,USB,LSB,CW,FM" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 212 Sat Aug 16 >> 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get dropdown-list {Wide}" ): -> "8000 >> Hz,6000 >> Hz,5700 Hz,5400 Hz,5100 Hz,4800 Hz,4500 Hz,4200 Hz,3900 Hz,3600 >> Hz,3300 >> Hz,3000 Hz" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 212 Sat Aug 16 >> 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get dropdown-list {Med}" ): -> "2850 >> Hz,2700 >> Hz,2550 Hz,2400 Hz,2250 Hz,2100 Hz,1950 Hz,1800 Hz,1650 Hz,1500 >> Hz,1350 >> Hz,1200 Hz" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 60 Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 >> 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get radio" ): -> "TT-OMNI VII (Radio)" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:730)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command: reply byte count: 162 Sat Aug 16 >> 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:757)Debug: >> HRDTransceiver::send_command( "get dropdown-list {Nar}" ): -> "1050 >> Hz,900 >> Hz,750 Hz,675 Hz,600 Hz,525 Hz,450 Hz,375 Hz,330 Hz,300 Hz" >> Sat Aug 16 21:15:37 2014 >> GMT(D:\JTSDK-QT\src\wsjtx\HRDTransceiver.cpp:214)Debug: HRD Dropdowns: >> QMap(("Med", ("2850 Hz", "2700 Hz", "2550 Hz", "2400 Hz", "2250 Hz", >> "2100 Hz", "1950 Hz", "1800 Hz", "1650 Hz", "1500 Hz", "1350 Hz", >> "1200 Hz") ) ( "Mode A" , ("AM", "USB", "LSB", "CW", "FM") ) ( "Mode >> B" , ("AM", "USB", "LSB", "CW", "FM") ) ( "Nar" , ("1050 Hz", "900 >> Hz", "750 Hz", "675 Hz", >> "600 Hz", "525 Hz", "450 Hz", "375 Hz", "330 Hz", "300 Hz") ) ( "Wide" >> , >> ("8000 Hz", "6000 Hz", "5700 Hz", "5400 Hz", "5100 Hz", "4800 Hz", >> "4500 Hz", "4200 Hz", "3900 Hz", "3600 Hz", "3300 Hz", "3000 Hz") ) ) > 73 > Bill > G4WJS. >> -----Original Message----- >> From: Bill Somerville [mailto:g4...@classdesign.com] >> Sent: Saturday, August 16, 2014 1:50 PM >> To: wsjt-devel@lists.sourceforge.net >> Subject: Re: [wsjt-devel] Bug in HRD TCP >> >> On 16/08/2014 19:00, Michael Black wrote: >> Hi Michael, >>> Using WSJT-X 1.40 as of 7/30/14 >>> >>> Bug: >>> HRD cat control doesn't not work over TCP/IP to port 7809 on HRD >>> 6.2.7.285 (also on previous release that I had) I assume I'm setting >>> it up correctly with 127.0.0.1:7809 and also tried with the setting >>> empty. >>> I get "Ham Radio Deluxe didn't respond as expected". >>> I snooped the network traffic and it does appear to be getting the >> "correct" >>> response >>> The problem seems to occur in here such that the "get dropdown" is >>> not matching what it expects (I added some #'s to the error messages >>> so I could tell where it was bombing). >> The problem with the HRD TCP/IP interface is that the commands are >> almost totally rig dependent, HRD makes no real attempt to abstract >> the concept of controlling a rig, it just provides a way of twiddling >> the on screen controls in HRD which themselves are rig dependent. >> >> You didn't say what rig you are using. >> >> There is extensive diagnostics already built in, you need to make a >> build with the following CMake options on: >> >> WSJT_QDEBUG_TO_FILE >> WSJT_QDEBUG_IN_RELEASE >> WSJT_TRACE_CAT >> >> then run that version up to the failure and send the file >> wsjtx_trace.log (in the directory of the executable) to me for analysis. >> >> It should only take a moment for me to add the fix as the HRD >> interface code is designed to add new rig fixes very quickly. >> >> If you can get the file to me before early tomorrow morning UK time I >> can have a go at a quick fix, otherwise I am off line for a week or so >> from tomorrow. >> >>> int HRDTransceiver::get_dropdown (int dd, bool no_debug) { >>> auto dd_name = dropdown_names_.value (dd); >>> auto reply = send_command ("get dropdown-text {" + dd_name + "}", >>> no_debug); >>> auto colon_index = reply.indexOf (':'); >>> >>> if (colon_index < 0) >>> { >>> >>> #if WSJT_TRACE_CAT >>> qDebug () << "HRDTransceiver::get_dropdown bad response"; >>> #endif >>> >>> throw error {tr ("Ham Radio Deluxe didn't respond as >>> expected#1\n"+reply)}; >>> } >>> >>> Q_ASSERT (reply.left (colon_index).trimmed () == dd_name); >>> return lookup_dropdown_selection (dd, reply.mid (colon_index + >> 1).trimmed >>> ()); >>> } >>> >>> I am able to use HRD over 3rd party serial port just fine with >>> Kenwood >>> TS-2000 setting. >>> >>> >>> Mike W9MDB >> 73 >> Bill >> G4WJS. >> >> ---------------------------------------------------------------------- >> ------ >> -- >> _______________________________________________ >> wsjt-devel mailing list >> wsjt-devel@lists.sourceforge.net >> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/wsjt-devel >> >> >> ---------------------------------------------------------------------- >> -------- _______________________________________________ >> wsjt-devel mailing list >> wsjt-devel@lists.sourceforge.net >> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/wsjt-devel > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- > -- > _______________________________________________ > wsjt-devel mailing list > wsjt-devel@lists.sourceforge.net > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/wsjt-devel > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ > _______________________________________________ > wsjt-devel mailing list > wsjt-devel@lists.sourceforge.net > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/wsjt-devel ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ _______________________________________________ wsjt-devel mailing list wsjt-devel@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/wsjt-devel
