On May 5, 2007, at 5:24 PM, Maciej Stachowiak wrote:
Your other Formal Objection was to Dave and Ian as editors, and
your proposed alternative is to add someone from the Forms WG as a
co-editor for the Forms section. I also disagree with that, as I
think it would lead to a lot of arguing and slow down work; and
because I think editors should be chosen based on their
qualifications and experience, not based on being members of an
external Working Group.
My proposed compromise for that is that the HTML WG and Forms WG
together in the Forms Task Force co-edit a Forms Architectural
Consistency Requirements document which XForms and HTML Forms both
then satisfy. I think this will accomplish the desire for closer
alignment with less likelihood of conflict delaying progress. Do
you have a different proposed compromise?
I noticed that you've withdrawn this objection. My offer above still
stands, however.
Regards,
Maciej
