+1 (with some thoughts below)
Brian Minchau wrote:
Hello,
I'm formally calling for a vote on this proposition which is to transform
Xalan from a sub-project of the Apache top-level XML project into a
top-level Apache project of its own.
1. The top-level Xalan project will contain the existing Xalan-J and
Xalan-C projects.
2. The top-level Xalan project will initially contain no sub-projects.
3. The initial committers for this project will be the existing committers
of the Xalan-J and Xalan-C.
4. The initial PMC members for this project will be Santiago
Pericas-Geertsen and Brian Minchau, who are the existing PMC members for
Xalan.
Should there be others?
5. The initial PMC Chairperson will be Brian Minchau.
+1
6. The initial mission statement will be
http://xml.apache.org/mission.html, although terms such as "xml.apache.org
project" should be read as "Xalan project".
-------------------------------------
In January and February of 2004 the idea of converting Apache XML project
into a "Federation" of top-level projects was discussed.
(see
http://nagoya.apache.org/wiki/apachewiki.cgi?XMLProjectPages/FederationProposal)
The reason this proposal is that the Apache Software Foundation by-laws
make assumptions about its structure, and the Board is concerened about
legally defending itself, such as better accountability on whether a given
release of a product was sanctioned. Releases, for example, are supposed to
be voted on by the PMC members responsible for a product. There needs to be
a verifiable link between the Board and the decision to make a release.
From a practical point of view I don't see that we are going to loose any
connection with other sub-projects of the XML project. That connection is
either there or not, and being a top-level project won't change that.
Being a top-level project will keep the management of Xalan clear of the
other XML sub-projects.
In the future I see Xalan's own mission statement, with more realistic
rules on voting, but that is not part of this proposal.
Here is my +1 vote.
----------
Brian Minchau
XSLT Development, IBM Toronto
e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
