>why are you doing that ? imho, you should not redirect port 25 traffic so
>that users that already have a valid smtp gateway can use it directly. you
>should also have your own enable smtp gateway for users that cannot use an
>external mta.

Hi Davide,

The problem is that hotel guests have all sorts of different mail settings.
For example one guest may be from Germany and his smtp settings
are smtp.localisp.de another guests may be from Zimbabwe and her
smtp settings will be smtp.localisp.zw.

If I did not do SMTP redirection, the guest would try to send email, their
computer would connect to their ISP's smtp server, and their SMTP
server would most likely give a '550 relay denied' error.

When I transparently redirect port 25, the person does not have to change
their smtp server. Their mail automatically gets redirected to the xmail 
server,
then the xmail server sends the email. The user has no idea what is going on in
the background, they just know that their email was sent. This works very well
for 95% of of the hotel guests.

The problem with the other 5% of guests is that they may have SMTP-AUTH
enabled, and when the transparent redirection takes place, the local xmail 
server
does not accept the user name and password.

In an ideal world, everyone would have smtp-auth enabled and I would not 
have to
do SMTP redirection, but unfortunately this being a hotel, most of the 
users are from
all over and they all have different settings. Also, the hotel is VERY 
opposed to having
the guests change ANYTHING on their computer, even IP addresses, mail 
settings etc...
So you can see the problem I have. :)

Anyways, I certainly am not asking you to change your program (which is the 
best
MTA I have found btw) but I am wondering if there is some setting I can 
change to permit
any username/password combo to work. Thanks for your help.

Riaz...



-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe xmail" in
the body of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For general help: send the line "help" in the body of a message to
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to