Jirka Kosek wrote:
> Hussein Shafie wrote:
> 
>>   * XXE_install_dir/doc/rnsupport/config/docbook5/
>>     now contains a ready-to-use configuration for
>>     DocBook V5.0b1. Previously, this directory
>>     contained a configuration which could be used
>>     to create documents conforming to DocBook NG,
>>     the "Lillet" release.
>>
>>     Remainder: do not use this configuration for
>>     serious work (even if it is almost as usable
>>     as the normal, DTD-based, configuration). This
>>     configuration has mainly been created to test
>>     the support of RELAX NG in XXE.
> 
> could you be more specific about reasons why you wouldn't recommend it
> for serious work?

This is a word of caution for the naive user. For a naive user, it is
clearly not a good idea to start authoring DocBook 5 documents using
XXE. The naive user should better stick to DocBook 4.4.

> In a near future I will have to create customized version of DocBook and
> I was thinking about doing this customization on the top of DocBook
> V5.0, because it is much easier to create customizations in RELAX NG. 

I understand.

> I hoped that XXE is offering same DocBook functionality for DTD based V4.x
> and for RELAX NG based V5.0.

Unfortunately, this is currently not the case. For example:
* you cannot split <para>s by simply pressing Enter;
* the DocBook menu lacks a "Convert Document" submenu.
And there are probably a few more rough edges I didn't notice...

---
PS: XMLmind is committed to fully support DocBook/RELAX NG in its free
XMLmind XML Editor Standard Edition.

Reply via email to