Monday, June 11, 2007, 10:06:41 AM, Hussein Shafie wrote:

> Daniel Dekany wrote:
>> In the default CSS you show the content html>head>title with huge
>> letters and positioned to center, on the white "paper" background,
>> with heading colors (brown). Like a super-h1. It's confusing because
>> of the semantic of the title element; unlike h1 and like, the title is
>> usually not meant to be "on the paper", it's rather a label, a
>> meta-information attached to the document. So, I believe it should be
>> rendered differently, like with normal size white bold letters, on
>> blue background, or something like that. It suggests that it's usually
>> a "window title". 
>
> That's right... in the case of a Web browser.

The "window title" thing was just an example of course. The point is
that the XHTML title element is not meant to be "on the paper". It's a
semantical thing; the title element is to *identify* the contents of a
document -- it's not part of the content. It's meta-info. It's not
inside the body element. Look at some XHTML-s. The big nicely
formatted title that you see at the top of XHTML pages is almost
always a H1, and practically never the html>head>title. It's not its
intended usage. With the default CSS, XXE 3.6.0 shows the title
element in a way that doesn't reflect the meaning of it.

>> It would be more helpful and more pleasing for almost most users,
>
> There is no way to be sure of that.

But you must guess, as you have to write a CSS (and you did). And
surely you shouldn't chose one of the less probable possibilities in
the out-of-the-box CSS.

>> I think, and it's surely no more than 5 minutes to
>> fix. 
>
> Our CSS style sheets cannot possibly please all XXE users. If you don't
> like something in them, please change it yourself.

With this logic you could render elements in whatever wildly absurd
ways in the default CSS, like p-s with 24pt bold, and H1-s with 12 pt
normal and what not, by saying that users can customize the CSS if
they have other preferences. :) Now really, the less users have to
customize the out-of-the-box CSS to be satisfied, the better your
product is, right?

> How to do that cleanly (that is, changes that survive XXE upgrades)
> is explained here:
> http://www.xmlmind.com/xmleditor/_distrib/doc/configure/customizing.html

-- 
Best regards,
 Daniel Dekany


Reply via email to