[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/YARN-6959?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
Yuqi Wang updated YARN-6959:
----------------------------
Description:
*Issue Summary:*
Previous attempt ResourceRequest may be recorded into current attempt
ResourceRequests. These mis-recorded ResourceRequests may confuse AM Container
Request and Allocation for current attempt.
*Issue Pipeline:*
{code:java}
// Executing precondition check for the incoming attempt id.
ApplicationMasterService.allocate() ->
scheduler.allocate(attemptId, ask, ...) ->
// Previous precondition check for the attempt id may be outdated here,
// i.e. the currentAttempt may not be the corresponding attempt of the
attemptId.
// Such as the attempt id is corresponding to the previous attempt.
currentAttempt = scheduler.getApplicationAttempt(attemptId) ->
// Previous attempt ResourceRequest may be recorded into current attempt
ResourceRequests
currentAttempt.updateResourceRequests(ask) ->
// RM may allocate wrong AM Container for the current attempt, because its
ResourceRequests
// may come from previous attempt which can be any ResourceRequests previous AM
asked
// and there is not matching logic for the original AM Container
ResourceRequest and
// the returned amContainerAllocation below.
AMContainerAllocatedTransition.transition(...) ->
amContainerAllocation = scheduler.allocate(currentAttemptId, ...)
{code}
*Patch Correctness:*
Because after this Patch, RM will definitely record ResourceRequests from
different attempt into different objects of
SchedulerApplicationAttempt.AppSchedulingInfo.
So, even if RM still record ResourceRequests from old attempt at any time,
these ResourceRequests will be recorded in old AppSchedulingInfo object which
will not impact current attempt's resource requests and allocation.
*Concerns:*
The getApplicationAttempt function in AbstractYarnScheduler is so confusing, we
should better rename it to getCurrentApplicationAttempt. And reconsider whether
there are any other bugs related to getApplicationAttempt.
was:
*Issue Summary:*
Previous attempt ResourceRequest may be recorded into current attempt
ResourceRequests. These mis-recorded ResourceRequests may confuse AM Container
Request and Allocation for current attempt.
*Issue Pipeline:*
{code:java}
// Executing precondition check for the incoming attempt id.
ApplicationMasterService.allocate() ->
scheduler.allocate(attemptId, ask, ...) ->
// Previous precondition check for the attempt id may be outdated here,
// i.e. the currentAttempt may not be the corresponding attempt of the
attemptId.
// Such as the attempt id is corresponding to the previous attempt.
currentAttempt = scheduler.getApplicationAttempt(attemptId) ->
// Previous attempt ResourceRequest may be recorded into current attempt
ResourceRequests
currentAttempt.updateResourceRequests(ask) ->
// RM may allocate wrong AM Container for the current attempt, because its
ResourceRequests
// may come from previous attempt which can be any ResourceRequests previous AM
asked
// and there is not matching logic for the original AM Container
ResourceRequest and
// the returned amContainerAllocation below.
AMContainerAllocatedTransition.transition(...) ->
amContainerAllocation = scheduler.allocate(currentAttemptId, ...)
{code}
*Patch Correctness:*
Because after this Patch, RM will definitely record ResourceRequests from
different attempt into different objects of
SchedulerApplicationAttempt.AppSchedulingInfo.
So, even if RM still record ResourceRequests from old attempt at any time,
these ResourceRequests will be recorded in old AppSchedulingInfo object which
will not impact current attempt's resource requests and allocation.
*Concerns:*
The getApplicationAttempt function in AbstractYarnScheduler is so confusing, we
should better rename it to getCurrentApplicationAttempt. And reconsider whether
there are any other bugs related to getApplicationAttempt.
> RM may allocate wrong AM Container for new attempt
> --------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: YARN-6959
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/YARN-6959
> Project: Hadoop YARN
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: scheduler
> Affects Versions: 2.7.1
> Reporter: Yuqi Wang
> Assignee: Yuqi Wang
> Labels: patch
> Fix For: 2.7.1, 3.0.0-alpha4
>
>
> *Issue Summary:*
> Previous attempt ResourceRequest may be recorded into current attempt
> ResourceRequests. These mis-recorded ResourceRequests may confuse AM
> Container Request and Allocation for current attempt.
> *Issue Pipeline:*
> {code:java}
> // Executing precondition check for the incoming attempt id.
> ApplicationMasterService.allocate() ->
> scheduler.allocate(attemptId, ask, ...) ->
> // Previous precondition check for the attempt id may be outdated here,
> // i.e. the currentAttempt may not be the corresponding attempt of the
> attemptId.
> // Such as the attempt id is corresponding to the previous attempt.
> currentAttempt = scheduler.getApplicationAttempt(attemptId) ->
> // Previous attempt ResourceRequest may be recorded into current attempt
> ResourceRequests
> currentAttempt.updateResourceRequests(ask) ->
> // RM may allocate wrong AM Container for the current attempt, because its
> ResourceRequests
> // may come from previous attempt which can be any ResourceRequests previous
> AM asked
> // and there is not matching logic for the original AM Container
> ResourceRequest and
> // the returned amContainerAllocation below.
> AMContainerAllocatedTransition.transition(...) ->
> amContainerAllocation = scheduler.allocate(currentAttemptId, ...)
> {code}
> *Patch Correctness:*
> Because after this Patch, RM will definitely record ResourceRequests from
> different attempt into different objects of
> SchedulerApplicationAttempt.AppSchedulingInfo.
> So, even if RM still record ResourceRequests from old attempt at any time,
> these ResourceRequests will be recorded in old AppSchedulingInfo object which
> will not impact current attempt's resource requests and allocation.
> *Concerns:*
> The getApplicationAttempt function in AbstractYarnScheduler is so confusing,
> we should better rename it to getCurrentApplicationAttempt. And reconsider
> whether there are any other bugs related to getApplicationAttempt.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.4.14#64029)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: yarn-issues-unsubscr...@hadoop.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: yarn-issues-h...@hadoop.apache.org
