Mostly we're trying to extend it. We were going to do it earlier but I've become nervous about changing the data type in the database without further testing. I have a bunch of good ideas about storing freeform notes that I'd love to get out there at some point...
Naturally we have limited people with which to do stuff so I have to make decisions as to what goes in, when, etc. Not that this has changed from previously. The limit is something we should definitely do (although I believe it will still be buggy; the form will count characters and the db counts bytes.) Joshua -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Ericka Menchen Trevino Sent: Friday, April 14, 2006 8:50 AM To: Lindsay Donaghe Cc: Larson, Timothy E.; [email protected] Subject: Re: [delicious-discuss] notes maximum length? This discussion, I think, hints at a larger issue. Is del.icio.us a service that people should expect something (like reasonable notification of data truncation) of? Or is it still something that people shouldn't expect so much? Because, really, it's probably 1% or less of the bookmarks on the system where the note is truncated. Perhaps dealing with this doesn't make it onto the to do list. We're not customers, really, we don't even look at ads, so sometimes I think we should just be grateful for whatever it does, other times I really wish it would do the little things I think are important - which are perhaps 'fringe' types of things in someones estimation, or perhaps are being worked on behind the scenes since companies can't be transparent with their plans b/c of competition etc. What I'm trying to say here is that it's puzzling, not that I'm unhappy with del or yahoo or anyone else. Are we customers now that del is yahoo owned? It's easiest to say we're "users" or "contributors" but what does that really mean in terms of how delicious relates to us? Also, it's relevant to know what was bought when yahoo bought delicious? Was it just the technology, the "community," the actual data in the database? I'm sure it was some combination, but probably one was more important. It will eventually be evident from their actions I suppose. -Ericka On 4/14/06, Lindsay Donaghe <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Well, people do use del.icio.us in different ways. Maybe a lot (or even > most) people don't write long comments or comments at all, but others do. I > think the people who do use the comments feature contribute a good bit to > the del.icio.us community and should be encouraged. Many times I've > depended on the comments to help me decide whether a link was worth clicking > on. > > I use comments to help me make better searches. I try not to clutter my > tags with stuff that will only be used once (though I'm not perfect at it!) > and the description field gives me the opportunity to put extra key words or > phrases that I don't feel belong as tags so that I can find stuff again > easily through search. > > It would be a very simple modification to add the maxlength attribute to the > description and then would not cause the frustration of having your text > truncated. You'd know immediately where the limit was. It's just a > usability issue. > > I know there has to be a limit, depending on what kind of database you're > using, the char types are typically limited at 256 characters, I think, so > making it bigger would require changing the type which is a major > enhancement, I know. But if that can't easily happen, keeping me from > losing data at the start would still be nice. > > > Lindsay > > > On 4/14/06, Larson, Timothy E. <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Lindsay Donaghe wrote: > > > Could you please have the max length set on text box that you can type > > > the description in so that you don't type a whole paragraph and then > > > find it truncated when you look at your saved link? I end up with > > > that happening all the time and it would be really easy to prevent > > > from del.icio.us < http://del.icio.us/> 's side just by setting the > > > maxlength attribute on the text area. And then people wouldn't have > > > to wonder what the max length is. > > > > > > I just hate losing data and having things cut off in mid-sentence or > > > even mid-word. > > > > When I was planning my own bookmark manager (before I discovered > > del.icio.us) I also realized the need to truncate notes at some point. > > I'd also decided on 255, but was going to have the engine be smart > > enough to back up to the preceding whitespace and add ellipsis there to > > indicate the truncation. But then, I'd already decided I was perfectly > > fine with silent truncation. > > > > > Even better (but probably less likely) it would be nice if we could > > > have more than 255 characters to work with. About double that would > > > be a lot more useful for me. > > > > Gotta cut it somewhere. 255 chars is roughly 40 words (in English). I > > think in a majority of cases that's sufficient for a > > reminder/summary/snippet. Most of my links don't have descriptions, and > > those that do are not very verbose. > > > > Tim > > -- > > Tim Larson > > West Corporation, Interactive TeleServices > > _______________________________________________ > > discuss mailing list > > [email protected] > > http://lists.del.icio.us/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss > > > > > _______________________________________________ > discuss mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.del.icio.us/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss > > > _______________________________________________ discuss mailing list [email protected] http://lists.del.icio.us/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss _______________________________________________ discuss mailing list [email protected] http://lists.del.icio.us/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
