http://www.ibnlive.com/news/why-i-am-afraid-of-mayawati/40458-3.html


Why I am afraid of Mayawati
By Hindol Sengupta

Mayawati's historic victory has left me speechless. And scared. Her
victory tells me once again how I, and people like me, have no voice
in Indian politics anymore. We, the middle-class, educated,
metro-bred, Christian-education raised, young. We, the backbone of the
knowledge, entreneurial economy. We, who have no representation. We
have no voice. We have no one who speaks our language, our idiom.


We are the people who rejoice every time Manmohan Singh takes stage.
He is us. He is the success of education and middle class values
rising to the top. Only, shudder, he failed to win a poll.


We, the non-vote bank. We, who must remember that Manmohan Singh rises
because of Sonia Gandhi. Because of loyalty to the Family. We, who
form no mass base.


Actually, you know, if you ask many like me, we are happy to be with
the Gandhis and their Family-Is-All-ness than the Mayawatis and the
Mulayams of the world. The Gandhis speak our langauge, they, we hope
have our concerns, and they, we hope express it, in our words.


All that might be untrue. But if you go by pure instinct, Rahul and
Priyanka, and Sheila Dikshit, and Salman Khurshid and Mani Shankar A.
beat the Amar Singhs of the world anyday.


Analysts would scoff at such instincts, pundits would ridicule, but is
what I'm saying any different from the way people in the villages of
Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, in fact, in most parts of small town and
rural India vote?


Why does a Raja Bhaiya, renowned for throwing bodies of his opponents
in a croc-infested pond, so violent and corrupt that he is called
Kunda Ka Goonda, win elections? Why does Amar Mani Tripathi, accused
of murder, get votes? Because their electorate vote for one of their
own. It's the same logic that kept Lalu in power, that allowed him to
argue that development is nothing. He brought something more to his
voters - he was one of them, and for those who had been oppressed for
centuries, to see one of them in power, to see a CM who kept buffalos
in his backyard was intoxicating. It was a real sense of power. No
roads or electricity could beat that.


Mayawati, by the way, does the same. Unabashedly corrupt, one could
hardly argue that she stands for development. Crime-fighting, yes.
Afterall, she was the one who put an end to Raja Bhaiya's goondagiri.
But forward planning? Infrastructure ideas? Modernity? Mayawati, alas,
is the quintessential behenji.


And people like me, well, we have always disliked the behenjis, now we
are scared of them. They rule. We have no voice.


Truly, the masses have hit back and how. In fact, in many
circumstances, I am almost apologetic about by background. It is
sneered at. It is also 'firang', and 'angrez-loving', my love for the
couplet and British poetry and world cinema, and, and... and
everything, shunned by the Hindi heartland. The people who rule.


Let me tell you a story. I was covering a protest at a south Mumbai
art gallery against the attack on the art student in Baroda. After an
great conversation with the art critic Ranjit Hoskote, I stepped out
telling my camera person who terrible it is that freedom of expression
is being curbed by some goons. As a Hindu, and a practising Hindu at
that, I feel ashamed, I said.


My camera person frowned at me and said - that's not true! What they
have done is right! How dare they insult our gods!!


At that moment, and I am more than a little ashamed to say this but
its the truth, I suddenly became acutely aware of the difference
between my background and the background of the cameraperson. The
thing is, he has many a leader in the political spectrum. I have
barely a handful and as parties like the SP and the BSP rise, on a day
when Rajdeep Sardesai is discussing if Mayawati could one day become
PM, I am concious that I have no leader to look up too.


Priyanka Gandhi is far away. Rahul Gandhi has failed. Manmohan Singh
is a puppet. I am aware that were a Lalu or a Mayawati were ever to
become PM, I would have to choose to leave the country.


I, part of the first generation in India who have enough opportunities
to work abroad anytime they want, and yet choose to work at home for
less than 1/10th the salary. We do it because we believe we can push
this country to great heights. For the first time, opportunities at
home seem, though far less lucrative, attractive because we are
building a nation. A confident nation that will beat the world.


And if we are to do it, we want to see a leader we can look upto. We
need to see one of us. Mayawati cannot and never will be my leader.


This is a country that prides on it English-speaking, entrepreneurial
youth. We who represent India to the world. But we don't vote do we?
And why don't we? Because there's no one to vote for! Where is my
leader? The truth is, I don't have one. And that, as sophistication
deserts our politics, means perhaps one day I will have to leave.

Reply via email to