http://www.indiapress.org/gen/news.php/The_Hindu/400x60/0

SCs, STs being exploited to part with allotted land: court

Legal Correspondent

Powerful sections take advantage of poverty, ignorance


New Delhi: Influential persons cannot grab or take away land allotted
by the government to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes by
paying a meagre sum as sale consideration even if alienation is
allowed after a specified period, the Supreme Court held on Tuesday.

It gave this ruling while upholding a Karnataka High Court judgment
setting aside alienation of land allotted to the SCs/STs by the
government under State legislation.

A Bench consisting of Justices Tarun Chatterjee and Dalveer Bhandari
pointed out that the government of India had urged State governments
to enact law, on the lines of its model legislation, to prevent
alienation of land.

Writing the judgment, Justice Chatterjee said: "From the objects and
reasons of this law, it was evident that ignorance and poverty of the
SCs/STs were exploited by persons belonging to the affluent and
powerful sections to get sales or mortgages, either for a nominal
consideration or for no consideration at all." On account of this, the
SCs/STs became victims of circumstances.

"It is for this reason and to fulfil the purposes of the grant, it was
thought fit by the [Karnataka] legislature that the land, even if it
has been alienated, must be restored to the original grantee or his
heirs and legal representatives who are admittedly SCs and STs," the
Bench said.

In the instant case, Tejyanaika was allotted two acres and 20 guntas
in Chitradurga district in September 1955 with a condition that the
land be not alienated for 15 years. In July 1976, his legal heirs
executed an agreement to sell the land. Meanwhile, the State enacted
the law prohibiting sale of such land without government permission
and it came into force from January 1, 1979. When the government
wanted to take back the land allotted to Tejyanaika, citing the
prohibition in the 1979 law, it was contended that alienation was
permitted after 15 years and that the sale agreement was executed
before the new legislation came into force.

Dharma Naika, who purchased the land challenged the government's move
but the High court rejected his plea.

Dismissing his appeal against this judgment, the apex court said:
"From an overall consideration of the objects and reasons for which
this Act was introduced viz. to protect the right and interests of the
SCs and the STs in respect of the granted lands and the relevant
provisions of the Act, it is pellucid that the definition of
'transfer' under the Act includes an agreement for sale also."

'Null and void'

The sale deed was executed in October 1986 without prior permission of
the government. That being the position, the transfer was "null and
void" and no right, title [on] or interest in such land shall be
conveyed or be deemed ever to have conveyed by such transfer," the
Bench said.

Reply via email to