http://www.indianexpress.com/story/273786.html


"There are no Indians left, only OBCs, Dalits, Hindus, Muslims, and
you get your agent to get you your entitlement"
Lord Meghnad Desai at the EXPRESS

Posted online: Sunday, February 17, 2008 at 0051 hrs IST

• SHAILAJA BAJPAI: Very recently, Lord Desai paid his first visit to
Vadodara since the 2002 riots. It's the city of his birth and early
childhood. Lord Desai, you made a point of not going there all these
years, so what made you change your mind?


I have many relatives who live there. I did not go there earlier as a
mark of protest. Then, two things happened: first, Narendra Modi won
the elections again pretty decisively; and second, I got an invitation
to speak there. At that stage, I had a choice either to say no I will
never go to Gujarat or go. Basically, I went on a private visit, gave
a lecture and came away. Nobody noticed that I had not been there for
five years. It's always a peculiar decision one has to make in such
cases: if you visit, are you collaborating with evil by going there? I
think so: going there conveys some sort of approval. However, in
retrospect, why single out one place? I come to Delhi and many more
people were killed here (during the 1984 riots) than in Gujarat. No
one from the Congress has apologised for that. More and more, I am of
the view — as they say in films — der hai,andher nahin hai. Judgments
in the Bilkis Bano's case and the Best Bakery case indicate that
slowly the wheels of justice are grinding.


I think, eventually, civil society will learn not to rely on the state
for redressal of its grievances. The state does not exist to either
grant human rights or to guarantee human rights. You have to fight
your own fight to have them and when they are violated you have to
fight and you have to fight absolutely neutrally — you have to fight
for the human rights of the bad guys as well.


Many years ago, there was an argument about Taslima Nasreen, and one
woman said, 'I will defend Salman Rushdie because he is a good writer
but I will not defend Taslima Nasreen because she is not a good
writer'. And I said 'human rights are invented for bad writers, not
for good ones'.


• SHAILAJA BAJPAI: Take us back to your Vadodara childhood and your
eventful youth.




For me, Baroda was a beautiful little town with lovely buildings. I
come from a family background where there is lot of explicit and
implicit pressure on learning and learning fast. So when I was born,
the probability that I would have a degree was 99 per cent, the only
question was how soon I would get it. As far as I can remember, I was
always able to read and do mathematical tables. I used to recite
mathematical tables every night before going to bed. When I was 20 I
finished my MA and I got a scholarship to US. That's how I escaped the
IAS.


• SHAILAJA BAJPAI: Why did you choose to become an economist?


I did not want to do economics or science. I loathed mathematics. But
those days, if you had good marks, you went for science. I wanted to
do Sanskrit, but my family said no, there are no jobs with that. In
the 1950s, the anxiety about jobs for middle class people was
horrendous.


• UNNI RAJEN SHANKER: We know of your love for Hindi cinema but living
abroad, how did you manage to keep in touch with popular culture and
movies?


I am something of a fraud because what I am really very good on are
the films of my youth, from 1946 to 1961. I kept the interest going
and I try to see as much as I can — Chak De India and Om Shanti Om,
etc — but I don't have the intensity I used to have. When I was young,
I used to see films and talk about them endlessly. I believe cinema is
a medium for young people. I still want to capture the experience of
what cinema meant to us as young people at that time. My book on Dilip
Kumar was an attempt to do that.


• SANJAY ANAND: Name some of your favourite films.


There was Jogan, one of the most beautifully made films ever. Also,
one of the most sexually charged films ever, without Nargis-Dilip
Kumar even touching. It is about the futility of renunciation and the
culture that glorifies it. Then there is Andaz, which I have seen a
thousand times and K.L. Saigal's Devdas, which is even better than
Dilip Kumar's Devdas. Aag was one film in which Raj Kapoor poured his
heart out and of course there's Do Bigha Zameen.


• SANJAY ANAND: Do Bigha Zameen dealt with the displacement of farmers
and currently we are in the throes of debates over SEZ displacements
etc. Can we make connections between cinema and social change?


It is obviously a record of change and the cost of change. From my
perspective, change is not only inevitable but also always violent.
There is no such thing as pain-free good. In my youth we had the
promise of socialism. In the Labour Party, we had to abandon the hope
of socialism because we realised that the only way out was capitalism.


But change is always about the winners dropping the losers. So the
question is: who defends the losers? Are the losers going to be
displaced and impoverished, or displaced and modernised? The debate on
preserving tribal culture is peculiar because very often very fragile
tribal cultures can only be preserved if you keep people at levels of
extreme poverty, at extreme resource cost. That's the paradox. Fragile
cultures are very often about inequitable gender relations, maternal
mortality, infant mortality, etc. Is it better to keep people alive
longer or preserve their cultures? Or, can you do both?


• SANJAY SINGH: From being a student of economics to an economist, how
have your views changed?


A major way in which I have changed is thinking on political economy
and developing this notion of rethinking capitalism. This began to
happen at a time when the Labour Party in UK was losing again and
again and Mrs Thatcher was winning. She was every thing we disliked.
We could not understand why people were so stupid as to vote for her.
But we were stupid, not the people. That led to self-examination on
our part. We realised the UK had to undergo a change, the economy had
to be restructured and this could not be done painlessly. That taught
me that if you have to change, you have to take the risk of pain. A
real statesman is a person who can sell pain to the people as part of
a package which will give you gain. Such paradoxes have helped shape
my thinking. The labour laws in India: they are meant to protect jobs.
But if you protect jobs, you don't create employment. So we have
created conditions in which semi-skilled manual people are living in
rural areas in awful conditions. They are not brought into factories
in urban areas because somebody has decided that hiring and firing is
bad for workers. Yet urbanisation is most important for upliftment.


• ZEENAT NAZIR: Why have you called NREGA a horrible thing?


All you promise people is one hundred days of work. There are
alternative polices which could do better. NREGA says don't be mobile,
you stay there in the villages and jobs will come to you.
Historically, how have the poor got out of poverty? By their own
efforts and very often by migration. NREGA is a way of doing something
which is very well meaning, but it's a palliative, it is putting a
colourful Band Aid. It is not a solution to poverty.


• ZEENAT NAZIR: You had come up with an idea of distributing a dollar
a week through smart cards. Do you think this is still relevant?


I think it is a policy which will work. The only power that will
empower people is purchasing power. If you can get one dollar a week
directly, unmediated, to the poor person, you could remove a lot of
the current programmes. But this requires a lot of radical
non-paternal thinking.


• ZEENAT NAZIR: You have spoken of a grand alliance between Congress
and BJP. Do you think it is possible?


I made the suggestion of a Congress-BJP coalition on systematic
grounds. And the grounds haven't changed - inclusive coalitions are
extremely costly in economic terms. Even with nine per cent growth,
they are costly. I think a two-party coalition will be more economical
in terms of wastage of government money, than a 17-party coalition. I
don't take the communalism-secularism divide very seriously. What
matters is rule of law. Does everybody get equal treatment before law?
Or, do I have to, as an Indian citizen, go through an agent, my caste
agent or my religion agent, to get redressal? The way politics has
been constructed, especially since Mandal, that there are no citizens
left. There are no Indian citizens left, there are only OBCs and
Dalits and Hindus and Muslims, and you get your agent to get you your
entitlement. The British used to say India is not a country, it's a
collection of tribes, and wehave bought into that. This is not a zero
sum game, it's a negative sum game. Right now, political parties are
doing everything on a vote bank calculus. If you can't even assert the
minimum right of an Indian to live anywhere because you are afraid of
someone like Raj Thackeray who has no political base, there's
something very wrong. This has been the story of UPA politics for the
past three years.


What's important here is how we can grow. We know that the growth of
the Indian economy is no longer a function of who is in power. In the
20th century, you have had serious private sector efficiency. If we
have 60 per cent of our population in the rural areas, the only way to
grow is to get them out of villages into urban areas. That requires
15-20 per cent manufacturing growth. Manufacturing at the low-tech
end. The way China has transferred millions of people from rural area
to urban is by high-volume, low-tech production. This is not possible
under the current laws in India. To do this, you need a government
that can ignore the Left, change labour laws. A single party cannot do
it. You have to have two parties and then just go for growth for ten
years.


• SANJAY ANAND: You have spoken on the need for change. If, for the
first time, a black man or woman is elected US President, will it
change policies?


Not really. It's a good thing that a woman or black man will win, but
American politics is a politics run by a very deep establishment in
which there is very little room to manoeuvre for the President. The
system is designed in such a way that the president can only operate
in foreign affairs. In domestic affairs, there is absolutely no room
for maneouvre. To that extent Hillary Clinton is right that a
President may do small things, something different from another
president. For the Americans all this talk of change makes them
wonder: are things bad as they are? And do I really trust Obama to
change my life for the better? One of the difficult things in British
politics is to convince people that you will change life for the
better and you know how to change life for the better.


• ZEENAT NAZIR: Fuel have been hiked once again. What's your opinion
of the hike in fuel prices?


It's not enough. Why should you or I subsidise car drivers?


• ZEENAT NAZIR: So you are not of the view that duties need to be cut
on import of oil?


No. I come from a country where there is more than 100 per cent hike
on petrol prices, because car driving is bad, bad for the environment,
bad for the traffic and it should be discouraged. And if somebody is
driving, he can afford anything. Mercilessly tax them.


• Vikas Dhoot: Your views on globalisation?


I believe it's the most positive force in the world. Without
globalisation, India and China would not have been where they are
right now. The decline in Indian poverty levels from roughly 40 per
cent in 1980 to roughly 20 per cent would not have happened without
globalisation.


(The transcript was prepared by Aditi Nigam)


--
Subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a BLANK email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] OR, if you 
have a Yahoo! ID, by visiting http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to