http://sify.com/finance/fullstory.php?id=14610649

Caste discrimination bigger than steam engine
R Vaidyanathan/ DNA MONEY
Tuesday, 26 February , 2008, 10:35
Last Updated: Tuesday, 26 February , 2008, 11:35

A major debate on reservation in institutions of higher learning like
the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) and Indian Institutes of
Management (IIMs), etc is being conducted at the Supreme Court.

A five-member bench is looking into the issues pertaining to the
validity of the recently passed Act and also related matters like
creamy layer exclusion, etc.

It has recently come to light that the Aryan invasion theory is a
concoction by British politicians and academicians to justify their
invasion of the country.

Perhaps a similar situation is emerging in the context of caste
discrimination since the British had a vested interest in inventing
discrimination and viewed the heterogeneous and non-hierarchical
Indian society using the European framework of a feudal-bourgeoisie
divide.



The colonizers were part of the Abrahamic tradition, which believes in
homogenization, and the heterogeneous and non-conflicting Indian
society would not have suited their design. That might have led them
to construct a class-based discriminating society out of the multiple
sampradayas and castes co-existing peacefully. After all, history is
constructed to suit the colonisers and victors.

A discussion about backward classes is very often a debate on the
backward castes. The backwardness is defined to include social,
educational and economic aspects.

In practice, it is identified more with social and educational
backwardness and hence, many castes are classified (or, shall we say
declared) as backward and provided reservation in institutes of higher
learning in most states.

In Tamil Nadu, for example, a whopping 69 per cent is reserved for
these categories. One of the major arguments in favour of reservations
is that the backward castes are educationally backward due to
discrimination in the past and hence cannot compete with others.

History does not support the thesis of discrimination.

A renowned Gandhian, Dharampal, visited British and Indian archives
and reproduced reports based on surveys conducted by the British in
Madras, Punjab and Bengal presidencies during 1800-1830.

According to a detailed survey undertaken during 1822-25 in the Madras
Presidency (present day Tamil Nadu, a major part of present day Andhra
Pradesh and some districts of Karnataka, Kerala and Orissa), 11,575
schools and 1,094 colleges were in existence in the Presidency and the
number of students in them were 1,57,195 and 5,431, respectively.

More important in view of the current debates and assumption is the
unexpected and important information provided with regard to the broad
caste composition of the students. We find that the position as early
as the first part of nineteenth century was significantly in favour of
the backward castes as far as secular education was concerned.

Hence, the British-inspired propaganda that education was not
available to the so-called backward castes prior to their efforts is
not valid. The "secular" education was always a major tool in social
transformation prior to British rule.

It is also assumed that caste is a rigid hierarchical system, which is
oppressive. However, as observed by renowned sociologist Dipankar
Gupta, "In fact, it is more realistic to say that there are probably
as many hierarchies as there are castes in India. To believe that
there is a single caste order to which every caste from Brahmin to
untouchable would acquiesce ideologically is a gross misreading of
facts on the ground. The truth is that no caste, howsoever lowly
placed it may be, accepts the reason for its degradation."

The debate also does not take into account the fact that backwardness
is not a static phenomenon, but a dynamic one.

The great sociologist, M N Srinivas said, "An important feature of
social mobility in modern India is the manner in which the successful
members of the backward castes work consistently for improving the
economic and social condition of their caste fellows. This is due to
the sense of identification with one's own caste, and also a
realisation that caste mobility is essential for individual or
familial mobility."

May be, the time has come for us to question many of the beliefs and
myths perpetuated on educational backwardness. Politics does play a
major role in shaping the perceptions of the common man, but it is the
duty of academicians and other experts to look at issues more
dispassionately so that the future of educational enhancement of our
country is not impaired by mythical dogmas. We need "enquiring minds"
to investigate the inventions of British other than that of the steam
engine.

Reply via email to