http://www.mumbaimirror.com/net/mmpaper.aspx?page=article&sectid=3&contentid=200803012008030102174833592cf6462

Employee can be sacked for making false SC/ST claims

Supreme Court says anyone securing a job by producing false
caste/tribe certificate deprives a legitimate person belonging to
SC/ST of employment

Posted On Saturday, March 01, 2008


PTI

New Delhi: A person who secures employment by producing a false caste
or tribe certificate is liable to be terminated, Supreme Court has
ruled.

A three-judge Bench of Chief Justice K G Balakrishnan, Justices C K
Thakker and R V Raveendran quashed a Delhi High Court judgement which
directed the Centre to allow an employee to continue in service
despite holding the view that he had used a forged tribal certificate
to secure the job.

"When a person secures employment by making a false claim regarding
caste/tribe, he deprives a legitimate candidate belonging to scheduled
caste/tribe, of employment. In such a situation, the proper course is
to cancel the employment obtained on the basis of the false
certificate," the apex court observed in its judgement. The Bench said
cancelling such an employee's appointment was essential as the post
may be filled by a candidate who genuinely belongs to such reserved
post.

The apex court passed the ruling while upholding an appeal filed by
the Union government challenging the high court's judgement in the
case of Dattataray Mendhekar who got employment as Assistant Professor
of Psychiatry in G B Panth Hospital in New Delhi.

Dattataray was issued a show cause notice on March 15, 1999 asking him
why he should not be terminated from service for having produced a
false ST certificate and claiming that he belonged to the tribal Halba
community.

 In another ruling, supreme court says owner responsible if vehicle is
used for smuggling

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has ruled that the owner of a vehicle
used for smuggling cannot escape liability unless he proves that he
had no knowledge of the illegal act. "It is a matter which is within
his knowledge. Mere assertion without anything else will not suffice,"
said an SC Bench.

Interpreting the provision of the Indian Forest Act, the SC said it
was for the owner, his agent or any other person in charge of the
vehicle to prove that all "reasonable and necessary precaution," were
taken to prevent the misuse of the vehicle.

The Bench upheld an appeal of the West Bengal government against a HC
order. The HC had directed forest officials to return the Maruti Van
of Mahua Sarkar, which was seized for smuggling timber. Sarkar had
claimed that he had no knowledge of the smuggling as the van was given
to a friend of his and the driver misused it without his knowledge.

Reply via email to