http://www.dailypioneer.com/columnist1.asp?main_variable=Columnist&file_name=prasad%2Fprasad245.txt&writer=prasad
Kiosks of change By Chandrabhan Prasad Searching for an occupation for Dalit youth, those who drop out after Class VIII or X, I came across yet another occupation for them - selling paan/cigarettes. By any reckoning, the kiosk vendor is respected by the customers and the public in general. In comparison, sweeper or a cobbler is despised even within the community leave alone the larger caste-Hindu society. But, how much does an average paan/cigarette vendor earn? As I have already written in my earlier column a cobbler earns some where between Rs 100 to Rs 150 a day, a sweeper, some where between Rs 4,000 to Rs 5,000 a month. What surprised me was that a paan shop owner earned equivalent to, or more than what a lecturer gets! The vendor that I spoke to, sells 15 to 20 packets of the Classic range of cigarettes a day. The cost for the same is Rs 80. He gets a commission of Rs 9.50 on each packet he sells - earning between Rs 142 to Rs 190 a day on one brand of cigarette alone. He also sells a minimum of five packs of India Kings cigarettes costing Rs 100 and gets a commission of Rs13 thus making Rs 65 a day on this brand. He sells about 20 packs of Wills Navy cut cigarettes a day. Sold at Rs 34 for a pack, he gets a commission of Rs 2.75 - he makes another Rs 55 on this brand. In other words he earns Rs 300 by selling cigarettes alone. The shops in lower middle class localities may be selling fewer high range cigarette packs, but, sell as many packs of low price cigarettes. The low range Capstan cigarette is sold at Rs 19 a pack, the commission on it is Rs 1.40 a pack, his earning Rs 28 from this brand alone. He sells several other low brand cigarettes. According to my estimates, the vendor makes a minimum of Rs 100 by just selling cigarettes. Now let's see how much he makes by selling paan. Usually the cost of the paan is Rs three for a couple and he sells more than three couple-paans a day. The profit on the same - not less than Rs two per couple of paan. They also sell gutka, match boxes, and bidies. By my own conservative estimate, a paan/cigarette vendor in upper middle class and a rich locality earns over Rs 1,000 a day. Shops in lower middle class make a minimum of Rs 300 a day. By all accounts, he earns more than a cobbler or a sweeper. So the big question is - can the Dalits take to this occupation? To find out that, I took a tour of my locality, and counted the number of paan/cigarette shops. I found 45 such shops. If you look around any urban, semi-urban, and cosmopolitan city of India, one would find a paan/cigarette shop within a distance of 100 metres. In Delhi alone, there may be more paan/cigarette shops than the total number of sweepers and cobblers. A paan/cigarette seller requires no educational qualification. He requires no income/sales tax registration, and the investment can be often less than Rs 1,000. In other words, if the Dalit organisations, Governments and private sector practise what they preach, in less than a decade, all Dalits engaged in socially degrading occupations can be emancipated. For this the Dalit organisations need to reach out to Dalit households with the message that they should quit their present occupation imposed on them by history, and tell them the options available. The State Government should allot space to the youth. The private sector should embrace these youth, and give them the know-how on the selling technique and monitor their progress. If this is done, a million Dalit youth who have no formal education can be made to increase their earnings and be socially accepted.
