Sunday 21 December, 2008
Merit is Relative
MERIT IS RELATIVE
Reservation or Affirmative action is only a cosmetic instrument of
addressing social discrimination in India. It is anyway, however
disputed or superficial, required because of the innate inability of
Indian society to be just and fair by itself to all its
consituients.Reservation not only brings opportunity, empowerment and
order but also in a way tries to address the untouchability.
Today when there is resentment over reservation created by a section
of society with the help of media, it is imperative to reason the
various issues which were raised by the protestors.
One of the main argument is merit.Merit is only a relative term and no
one is meritorious by birth. Intelligence and pride is not distributed
according to castes. If the systems were fair for every caste, job
representation would have been broadly in proportion to its share in
the population. Some castes got a disproportionately large share of
opportunities even when many individuals therein didn't have the
necessary talents. So merit is an argument generally used against
reservation as a resistance by the so called high-born to give up the
'reservations' they have enjoyed unimpeded for centuries.The
Britishers were more meritorious than us in many fields, they gave us
law, judiciary and administrative system but we fought against them
because of non-representation of Indians in the governance of country.
If merit is to be awarded, we shouldn't have revolted against British
because they were more meritorious and hence fit for all posts.
Even Fifa world cup football is also about quota system. Regarded as
the finest, biggest and grandest event of sport is also representative
in nature. Teams like Togo, Tunisia, Trinidad and Tobago, Costa Rica
etc. are playing in cup more by the virtue of regional representation
rather than merit or talent. Teams like Hungry, Romania, Belgium,
Russia, Ireland, European champion Greece, previous semi-finalist
Turkey are much better teams but were not part of world cup. It is so
because football reaching more population will bring vast market, more
capital, more interest and participation with improved skill and
vividity.These factors would develop football, raise standards, become
spectacular. If meritocracy only is allowed, then probably only
Europeans and some Latin American countries shall play and stagnate
the game one day to kill it. No country or system can sustain its
growth momentum over longer period of time if only a small strata of
society has access to it.
World over businesses, military, sports and
education have given better results with people who come from diverse
background. People who have been in diverse atmosphere develop more
complex ways of thinking about issues in general. They learn to take
multiple perspectives on issues, thus it is erroneous to link
meritocracy exclusively to standardized tests, and tests are crucially
dependent upon persons' family backgrounds, their wealth and their
privileged schooling. In a country like India where there is enormous
inequality in system, it is hazardous to just admit on the basis of
tests (or merit); it will be perpetuating social stratification, not
just on caste but also on class ground.
That's why caste based reservation is the most effective way of
addressing social injustice. Economy can't be the basis of reservation
because in that way does somebody want to suggest he would be
comfortable compromising quality if caused by low-income? Or, is it
that only caste based reservation will harm quality.
Economic statistics will also tell that economic criteria is almost
equivalent to caste criteria of reservation, Infact, economics here is
subset of caste. 90% of poor are from SC/ST/OBC. 49% and 32% of SC and
ST population respectively are agriculture labours. 40% of child
labours in India are SC. Per capita income of SC is Rs3237 whereas
national average is Rs 4485.Averagely 75% of SC/ST population don't
have access to electricity as against national average of 52%. There
are more statistics but probably it can outnumber the words used in
this article.
Even affirmative action programme in US is successful because it
brought an order in American society. It was enforced by law somewhere
and others judiciously volunteered to implement. From Havard, IBM, to
Lockheed martin, today AA has helped them to connect to America which
has a vast population of Blacks, Hispanics and native Indians. But
there is large difference between AA in US and reservation in India,
as AA does not required addressing untouchability. In US institutions
and companies have decided that it is good to have more racial and
ethnic diversity. In India, reservation has been introduced from the
top with states intervention because here our private sector, unlike
that of US, has been indifferent to the idea of bringing marginalized
groups into the national mainstream and diversifying the professional
class.
Another scientific theory about intelligence quotient tells that IQ of
more than 120 is high intelligence and about 3% people generally have
it. If we consider our population of 1.2 billion of which the
workforce is 400 million. 3% of 400 million is 12 million.So, in a
truly meritorious society; 12 million people should have a high
position. In India, that is not the case. India is having at most 2
million top managers and professionals. That means10 million
intelligent people are missing action, they may be anywhere from
farmers to labours to cleaners to cobblers to milkman etc.It proves
that only few who have access and opportunity with good education,
good parents, good school and colleges are on top but at the same time
those 10 million people are rotting without opportunities. Thus,
nobody can claim altogether that reservation disposes merit. Many
intelligent people are unable to even race for good college or jobs.
Here in India, we count merit only for entrance to engineering,
medicine, other professional courses or some illustrious money
fetching jobs. Why not merit as per intelligence is counted in other
streams like farming, scavenging, labours etc.Merit is brought forward
as an argument when there is a question of powerful education or rich
jobs.M.S Swami Nathan is meritorious because he is a great agriculture
scientist but a farmer who efficiently produces farm products inspite
of social, infrastructural and economical restrictions is regarded as
non-meritorious or backward.
So, the society must address this wrong notion of merit. It is a
relative term and used as per the convenience. The whole debate gets
entrapped in the web of merit, fitness, efficiency, whereas, we are
still faraway from the basic argument or solution of addressing social
prejudices, inequality and discrimination. Reservation is just a small
tool to partially address problem of social discrimination, there are
far bigger and radical steps needed to be taken in order to make
egalitarian society where there will be no reservations.