Hari - It's very difficult to say how long this would take. There are a number of issues that need to be resolved by design rather than code. For example, the question of finding the cluster when the membership has changed is unanswered.
The changes to the core protocol will need substantial peer review and testing. Judging by my experience with the observers patch, which I think is comparable in size but probably less complex, I would expect about 3-6 months from the time someone picks up the work. cheers, Henry On 18 February 2010 12:28, Hariharan Subramanian <hurryha...@gmail.com>wrote: > Thanks to all of you that responded. This feature is also important to the > project I am working on. Although we would have to find someone with the > right skills to contribute to it. > > Henry, Do you have an estimate on how long this task would take if someone > were to start with your prototype? > > Thanks again > ~ Hari > > > On Thu, Feb 18, 2010 at 1:35 PM, Henry Robinson <he...@cloudera.com>wrote: > >> Hi - >> >> Yes, I'm still interested in this JIRA but it's a significant change to ZK >> which would be best suited for probably the 4.0 release. I have a rough >> implementation that 'works' but still leaves some issues unresolved. I >> don't >> have a great deal of time for this issue at the moment though, which is >> why >> it's stalled a bit - other ZK issues are more pressing. This would be a >> really great project for anyone looking for a meaty distributed systems >> project; I'm happy to offer guidance and advice if anyone wants to take it >> on! >> >> Henry >> >> On 18 February 2010 09:58, Patrick Hunt <ph...@apache.org> wrote: >> >> > There are ways to "dynamically" update the cluster membership today, >> > granted while they are dynamic they are not dynamic in the sense of 107: >> > http://bit.ly/bTTdDK (see item 6) >> > >> > 107 is still pending. Henry was interested to implement this, I'm not >> sure >> > his current status. Henry? I think this is a good feature to add, but it >> > brings up a number of issues that we need to work through. Given that >> most >> > ppl rarely change cluster membership, and the fact that there are >> options >> > available today, there hasn't been a lot of demand for this. >> > >> > Patrick >> > >> > >> > Hariharan Subramanian wrote: >> > >> >> Dear Zookeeper community, >> >> >> >> I would like to know the status of issue ZOOKEEPER-107 (Allow dynamic >> >> changes to server cluster membership) which is assigned to Henry >> Robinson >> >> >> >> Is this the right forum to ask this question or should I post an update >> to >> >> the bug report? >> >> >> >> Thanks >> >> -- Hari >> >> >> >> >> >> >> -- >> Henry Robinson >> Software Engineer >> Cloudera >> 415-994-6679 >> > > > > -- > --… …-- > .... .- .-. .. > -- Henry Robinson Software Engineer Cloudera 415-994-6679