Hi Travis, as Flavio suggested would be great to get the logs. A few
1) how did you eventually recover, restart the zk servers?
2) was the cluster losing quorum during this time? leader re-election?
3) Any chance this could have been initially triggered by a long GC
pause on one of the servers? (is gc logging turned on, any sort of heap
monitoring?) Has the GC been tuned on the servers, for example CMS and
4) what are the clients using for timeout on the sessions?
3.4 probably not for a few months yet, but we are planning for a 3.3.2
in a few weeks to fix a couple critical issues (which don't seem related
to what you saw). If we can identify the problem here we should be able
to include it in any fix release we do.
fixing something like 517 might help, but it's not clear how we got to
this state in the first place. fixing 517 might not have any effect if
the root cause is not addressed. 662 has only ever been reported once
afaik, and we weren't able to identify the root cause for that one.
One thing we might also consider is modifying the zk client lib to
backoff connection attempts if they keep failing (timing out say). Today
the clients are pretty aggressive on reconnection attempts. Having some
sort of backoff (exponential?) would provide more breathing room to the
server in this situation.
On 06/30/2010 11:13 PM, Travis Crawford wrote:
Hey zookeepers -
We just experienced a total zookeeper outage, and here's a quick
post-mortem of the issue, and some questions about preventing it going
forward. Quick overview of the setup:
- RHEL5 2.6.18 kernel
- Zookeeper 3.3.0
- ulimit raised to 65k files
- 3 cluster members
- 4-5k connections in steady-state
- Primarily C and python clients, plus some java
In chronological order, the issue manifested itself as alert about RW
tests failing. Logs were full of too many files errors, and the output
of netstat showed lots of CLOSE_WAIT and SYN_RECV sockets. CPU was
100%. Application logs showed lots of connection timeouts. This
suggests an event happened that caused applications to dogpile on
Zookeeper, and eventually the CLOSE_WAIT timeout caused file handles
to run out and basically game over.
I looked through lots of logs (clients+servers) and did not see a
clear indication of what happened. Graphs show a sudden decrease in
network traffic when the outage began, zookeeper goes cpu bound, and
runs our of file descriptors.
Clients are primarily a couple thousand C clients using default
connection parameters, and a couple thousand python clients using
default connection parameters.
Digging through Jira we see two issues that probably contributed to this outage:
Both are tagged for the 3.4.0 release. Anyone know if that's still the
case, and when 3.4.0 is roughly scheduled to ship?