Jon,

> Interesting discussion in other threads got me wondering
> whether I should have made some other choices when setting
> up my vtape environment.  Particularly whether I should
> have used LVM (Logical Volume Management) to create one
> large filesystem covering my multiple dedicated disks.
>
> Its a topic I do not recall being discussed, pros & cons.

I am using 7 disks of 3 (or is that 4) and 6 TB (should upgrade them all to 6TB
soon) almost dedicated to vtapes (the last disk also has a copy of the
deleted accounts). I have them configured as individual disks. The size
of my vtapes is also about 100GB and I am using a small chunck size, so
my disks end up being 80% full at least.

When I designed my vtape architecture, I decided to keep each disk
individual so that it can be put offline after usage. My idea was to
have a system that could prompt an operator to "mount a disk" before the
backup and the disk could be manually unmounted and safe stored each
day. It is taking advantage of the automount service on FreeBSD.

Mounting could be USD disk, or hot-swap. I never went very far in the
implementation. I wrote all that many years ago when vtapes were new and
limited to a single directory, that is why I wrote my own tape changer.

I knew about the risk of loosing a disk and it being a good portion of
consecutive backups. But what I had in mind was:

- have the system as simple and as portable as possible, so I can shove
  a disk in another machine and extract contents manually (during the
  great flood of Bangkok in 2011, I moved all the servers and also took
  all my hard disks from Amanda backup, but I did not need to move the
  rack mounted server itself);

- a side advantage of my own tape changer is that I can keep the older
  disks (each disk has an individual label, like any vtape has a label)
  (I have updated them from 500GB to 1TB to 3TB and soon to 6TB) and the
  vtapes are still known into tapelist (they are marked noreuse). If the
  need arise, I can still remount that old disk.

So far (10+ years) the only disk I had failling was the disk having the
holding partition, I guess it was because of excessive usage.

I understand that vtapes have evolved since I started using them, but my
system works for me so I never took the time to search any further.

Best regards,

Olivier

Reply via email to