>> http://bbc-hackday.dyndns.org:2825/
>> - the whole thing's stitched together with MusicBrainz artist ids

> Theoretically, it should be possible to stitch www.bbc.co.uk/music/ into
> this, too. 

we're currently working to make this so. the later + totp stuff is really just 
a prototype of how we could handle linked music data across the beeb

> That uses Musicbrainz data, 

ish. the tool used to generate the /music site has brainz ids as foreign keys 
but these aren't present across the full data set. this relationship will be 
reversed soon

> but I've no idea where the odd IDs
> come from. The Coral, for example, is
> http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/artist/m3qv/ but if you Google "m3qv" and
> "Coral", it just returns that page, so it looks like an ID arbitrarily made
> up by the BBC.

when we were developing the music site a view was taken (can't remember by 
whom) that butt ugly 36 character uuids might scare users. so new shorter 
opaque ids were introduced - kinda like pip keys 
(http://www.plasticbag.org/files/misc/pips_etech.pdf). these are made up on the 
fly - not programmatically derived from brainz ids and have no meaning outside 
/music

personally i'm kinda fond of brainz ids and would love to see them across 
/music, radio1, radio 3, bbc 2, bbc4, anywhere in the beeb with music content


> I shall endeavour to find the relationship out if you'd be interested;
> benefits are that /music links to all music content throughout the BBC,
> which is therefore a Good Thing.

better still - if other users of brainz like last.fm (i'm looking at you russ 
;-) ) could be persuaded to also expose their music resources using brainz ids, 
all music across the web could be linked up

u might call me a dreamer ;-)

<<winmail.dat>>

Reply via email to