Am Sa., 27. Jan. 2024 um 12:14 Uhr schrieb Arne Ploese via bug-lilypond <bug-lilypond@gnu.org>: > > Here you can find a > preview: > https://www.schott-music.com/de/preview/viewer/index/?idx=NTI0Mjcx&idy=524271&dl=0 > > Voice tenor bar 9 to 10 into first alternative it is bound, were as > from bar 9 to 13 (page 2) it isn't. > It is officially published by SCHOTT Music, so I think its correct... > > Arne > > > > There might be a small misunderstanding in "When a note is tied over > > > into two or more alternative endings [...]" this is also needed if > > > the tie goes only into the first alternative as well [...] > > > > From a logical point of view you either have no tie, or you have a tie > > that goes into *all* alternative endings. In other words, 'a tie that > > goes only into the first alternative' is incorrect. If you have such > > a situation you should consider changing where the alternatives > > actually start. > > > > Maybe there is a misunderstanding on my side, so please provide an > > example (with an image) that illustrates what you mean. > > > > > > Werner >
What should the Tenor do: tie into second alternative or not...? Schott is wrong. Cheers, Harm
