Source: gnupg2
Version: 2.4.4-1
Severity: minor

Starting 2.4.4-1, gnupg depends on mail-transfer-agent.  Unfortunately,
these days, less and less systems actually have email system configured,
especially home/laptop/etc systems (when email is done though a web UI).
We had mail-transfer-agent almost mandatory in debian for quite a while,
because cron used to depend on it for emailing status of failing jobs
(among others), - now cron is finally optional itself, and it's possible
to install a system without email.

And now it becomes mandatory once again, now coming from gnupg side.

Please note the function gnupg uses email for is very rarely used, -
it's been many years when gpg-wks-server has been built without even
specifying path to sendmail binary, it's been fixed only in #1025782
in 2024.

Please make m-t-a at least Recommends (instead of Depends), or even
better, - Suggests, because about 99.99% of gnupg users will never
need it but configuring mta is a real burden (and it even can't be
done in many cases).

Even better if gpg-wks-server itself becomes "more optional", - right
now it is installed on all my (at least desktop) systems.  But this
is a different matter it seems (looks more like bugs in other packages
who blindly depend on whole gnupg instead of certain components they
actually use).

Thanks,

/mjt

Reply via email to