On Wed, 2010-04-28 at 21:44 +0100, Neil Williams wrote: > On Wed, 28 Apr 2010 17:55:45 +0200 > "Hoefle Marco" <marco.hoe...@nanotronic.ch> wrote: > > > Hello, > > my first multistrap test was successful, I like this approach more > > Thanks, but please include the version of multistrap used. (This is > just one reason why bug reports are better than mailing list posts - > the version is included automatically.) My tests will be done with > multistrap 2.1.3 from Debian experimental and fixes will go into > multistrap 2.1.4, also heading into experimental. (Things need to > settle a bit more before I disturb 2.0.9 in unstable.) I upgraded to multistrap version 2.1.3 and used the multsitrap config you provided, see below. I will file a bug, but first I need to know if I am doing something wrong or if it is a bug :)
> > > than the old emsandbox I used before. > > > > A few points I have: > > - udev in grip squeeze (151-3em1) does not detect mtbblockx devices, > > (Seems to work on my Grip box... Have you tested the x86 package at > the same version? If so, have you reported a bug against the Debian > package?) > > > I replaced the udevd executables with an older version from another > > embedded distro and it worked as expected. Thus I tried this: > > [General] > > arch=armel > > directory=rootfs_unconfigured > > cleanup=true > > noauth=true > > unpack=true > > debootstrap=Grip > > aptsources=GripSqueeze GripLenny Debian > > Problem 1: > > bootstrap is for packages that you use to build the rootfs. > aptsources is for the sources you want listed inside the rootfs for > runtime. ok > > You won't get packages from GripLenny or Debian included in the initial > rootfs unless you list those sections in debootstrap. > > (That option will be renamed to bootstrap or rootfs in future, support > will be retained for the existing setting but I'll see about changing > the docs for clarity.) > > The distinction probably wasn't clear in the early versions of > multistrap. Please file a minor/wishlist bug so that I don't forget to > add / clarify the documentation. I fied on, number is 579626 > With that fixed, I get the version of udev you requested: > Get: 3 http://ftp.ch.debian.org lenny/main udev 0.125-7+lenny3 [259kB] > ... > > Selected version 0.17-29 (Debian:5.0.4/stable) for ftpd > Selected version 3:20100214-1em1 (EmdebianGrip:1.1/testing) for iputils-ping > Selected version 1:5.5p1-2em1 (EmdebianGrip:1.1/testing) for openssh-server > Selected version 0.17-36em1 (EmdebianGrip:1.0.1/stable, > EmdebianGrip:1.1/testing) for telnetd > Selected version 0.125-7+lenny3 (Debian:5.0.4/stable) for udev > Selected version 0.86-4em1 (EmdebianGrip:1.1/testing) for usbutils > > Problem 2: you don't specify a Grip section and you don't 'include' a > conf file that does. This is where multistrap needs to improve the > error reporting - please file a bug report against the Debian package > - minor, asking for clearer error reporting in the --simulate option. bug is 579627 > Note that it is *intentional* that mismatched values have no effect - > it is useful in how more complex configurations can be used. As with > other options, this is under review but would add a lot of code to fix. > (It could be added to the --simulate output - in a "did you forget this > bit" section with less code churn, I'll try that for 2.1.4 but file a > bug so that I don't forget.) > > > I still get the squeeze version instead of the the lenny one > > (0.125-7em1). > > Wrong config in bootstrap vs aptsources. See above. > > > -the ftpd package is missing in grip, thus I use the normal Debian > > repository. > > That can be added. (In fact, I just have - it'll find it's way into > Squeeze in due course.) > > > - I am configuring the generated multistrap fs with qemu-arm. I need > > Problem 3: Don't use qemu. Test locally - multistrap is > architecture-neutral in terms of whether the config works or not. > Override the architecture on the command line for tests. Then you can > test the chroot too. What are the commands? When I chroot into the unconfigured armel root fs folder it complains that /bin/bash cannot be run. It is not there and if it would it would be for armel not for i386. > > Problem 4: There was a bug in multistap which I'll fix in 2.1.4 > (experimental) where some Priority: required packages were omitted. You > can solve this in the meantime by explicitly adding 'dash' or 'bash' to > your GripSqueeze packages config. > > > DEBIAN_FRONTEND=noninteractive DEBCONF_NONINTERACTIVE_SEEN=true > > LC_ALL=C LANGUAGE=C LANG=C dpkg --configure -a results in: > > > > Errors were encountered while processing: > > dash > > ifupdown > > grip-config > > bash > > That is Debian bug 556402 - ifupdown has the wrong dependencies. > > I'm going to look at trying to force the dependencies in the Emdebian > repository but it's not a good fix. If it is a ifupdown bug I think it is not worth to spend time on it, I dont know about others but I could live with the bug. > > In the meantime, the removal of grip-config (see other email) means > that you don't get ifupdown unless you specifically require it. > > > and finally another configure -a succeeds with all packages. Would be > > nice if one configure is enough. > > Apart from ifupdown, this would have happened with a sorted config and > an explicit request for dash or bash. > > > I'm seeing one error with base-files - not sure how to fix this because > multistrap shouldn't generally go doing stuff to /etc/passwd (emsandbox > got into trouble doing that). > Setting up base-files (5.3em1) ... > chown: invalid user: `root:root' > dpkg: error processing base-files (--configure): > subprocess installed post-installation script returned error exit status 1 > > This can be solved using the "reinstall" config of the new multistrap > (i.e. base-files is complaining that a user has not been created, fails > and then it (magically) appears later.) > > Also, as grip-config is in Lenny (and cannot be removed from Lenny), > I've avoided using GripLenny in my tests of the rest of the config. If > there is a real bug in udev, it needs to be tested with the Debian > package, reported to Debian and fixed. > > Adapted config: (Requires multistrap 2.1.3 or 2.1.4.) > > Simulate report (includes my command line overrides for testing): > Bootstrap: debian, gripsqueeze > Apt sources: debian, gripsqueeze > Includes: > Sources: http://ftp.uk.debian.org/debian/, http://www.emdebian.org/grip, > http://www.emdebian.org/grip > Packages: ftpd, udev, usbutils openssh-server telnetd dash udev > Suites: lenny, lenny, sid > Components: main, main, main > reinstall: base-files > arch: amd64 > dir: /tmp/multistrap/ > unpack: true > no_authentication: 1 > > conf file: > (I had to change the debian mirror to get a fast enough download speed.) > > [General] > arch=armel > directory= > cleanup=true > noauth=true > unpack=true > debootstrap=GripSqueeze Debian > aptsources=GripSqueeze Debian > > [GripSqueeze] > packages=usbutils openssh-server iputils-ping telnetd dash udev > source=http://www.emdebian.org/grip > reinstall=base-files > keyring=emdebian-archive-keyring > suite=sid > > [GripLenny] > packages=udev > source=http://www.emdebian.org/grip > keyring=emdebian-archive-keyring > suite=lenny > > [Debian] > packages=ftpd > source=http://ftp.uk.debian.org/debian/ > keyring=debian-archive-keyring > suite=lenny > > Thanks for the test - please report the bugs and test again using at > least 2.1.3 from experimental or (ideally) once 2.1.4 appears in > experimental. I tested with 2.1.3, it cannot find packages which where there yesterday using 2.0.9: [General] arch=armel directory=rootfs_unconfigured cleanup=true noauth=true unpack=true debootstrap=GripSqueeze Debian aptsources=GripSqueeze Debian [GripSqueeze] packages=usbutils openssh-server iputils-ping telnetd dash udev source=http://www.emdebian.org/grip reinstall=base-files keyring=emdebian-archive-keyring suite=sid [GripLenny] packages=udev source=http://www.emdebian.org/grip keyring=emdebian-archive-keyring suite=lenny [Debian] packages=ftpd source=http://ftp.ch.debian.org/debian/ keyring=debian-archive-keyring suite=lenny hoe...@wks02-lin:/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip$ sudo multistrap -f grip-config multistrap 2.1.3 using grip-config Using foreign architecture: armel multistrap building armel multistrap on 'i386' Getting package lists: apt-get -o Apt::Architecture=armel -o Apt::Get::AllowUnauthenticated=true -o Apt::Get::Download-Only=true -o Apt::Install-Recommends=false -o Dir=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/ -o Dir::Etc=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/etc/apt/ -o Dir::Etc::SourceList=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/etc/apt/sources.list.d/multistrap.sources.list -o Dir::State=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/var/lib/apt/ -o Dir::State::Status=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/var/lib/dpkg/status -o Dir::Cache=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/var/cache/apt/ update Hit http://ftp.ch.debian.org lenny Release.gpg Ign http://ftp.ch.debian.org lenny/main Translation-en_US Hit http://ftp.ch.debian.org lenny Release Ign http://ftp.ch.debian.org lenny/main Packages/DiffIndex Ign http://ftp.ch.debian.org lenny/main Sources/DiffIndex Hit http://ftp.ch.debian.org lenny/main Packages Hit http://ftp.ch.debian.org lenny/main Sources Hit http://ftp.uk.debian.org lenny Release.gpg Ign http://ftp.uk.debian.org lenny/main Translation-en_US Hit http://ftp.uk.debian.org lenny Release Ign http://ftp.uk.debian.org lenny/main Packages/DiffIndex Ign http://ftp.uk.debian.org lenny/main Sources/DiffIndex Hit http://www.emdebian.org sid Release.gpg Ign http://www.emdebian.org sid/main Translation-en_US Hit http://ftp.uk.debian.org lenny/main Packages Hit http://www.emdebian.org sid Release Ign http://www.emdebian.org sid/main Packages/DiffIndex Hit http://ftp.uk.debian.org lenny/main Sources Ign http://www.emdebian.org sid/main Sources/DiffIndex Ign http://www.emdebian.org sid/main Packages Ign http://www.emdebian.org sid/main Sources Hit http://www.emdebian.org sid/main Packages Hit http://www.emdebian.org sid/main Sources Reading package lists... Done apt-get --force-yes -y -o Apt::Architecture=armel -o Apt::Get::AllowUnauthenticated=true -o Apt::Get::Download-Only=true -o Apt::Install-Recommends=false -o Dir=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/ -o Dir::Etc=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/etc/apt/ -o Dir::Etc::SourceList=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/etc/apt/sources.list.d/multistrap.sources.list -o Dir::State=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/var/lib/apt/ -o Dir::State::Status=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/var/lib/dpkg/status -o Dir::Cache=/media/ext3_data/projects/haslerrail/emdebian_eval/multistrap_test/multistrap_grip/rootfs_unconfigured/var/cache/apt/ install dash/sid debian-archive-keyring emdebian-archive-keyring ftpd/lenny iputils-ping/sid openssh-server/sid telnetd/sid udev/lenny udev/sid usbutils/sid Reading package lists... Done Building dependency tree... Done E: Release 'sid' for 'dash' was not found apt download failed. Exit value: 100 -- -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-embedded-requ...@lists.debian.org with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org Archive: http://lists.debian.org/1272534033.8098.76.ca...@srv03-lin.nanotronic.local
