I've been working on generating geronimo-plugin.xml from the pom.xml and am really confused about what should be in some of the elements. I wonder if we need to add more information for more clarity.

For instance, the dojo configs currently say:

    <url>http://dojotoolkit.org/</url>
    <author>Dojo Foundation</author>
<license osi-approved="true">BSD and Academic Free License v2.1</ license>

This is appropriate for dojo itself but I think its misleading for our repackaging of dojo to run in geronimo.

Since we are distributing the car file from apache I think the license has to be asl2. That's certainly what we're including in the car file itself.

Similarly the dojo guys don't know anything about our distribution so pointing to them seems a bit misleading.

What I can set up automatically from the pom uses the info there, which I think is more appropriate. I get

    <url>http://geronimo.apache.org/</url>
    <author>The Apache Geronimo development community</author>
<license osi-approved="true">The Apache Software License, Version 2.0</license>

I think it would be more appropriate to put the stuff about the dojo organization in the description or in some additional optional "content-author" type elements.

thoughts?

thanks
david jencks

Reply via email to