Adam K Kirchhoff
Sun, 05 Mar 2006 16:37:06 -0800
I had some time yesterday and thought I'd do a quick comparision of the DRI drivers and fglrx drivers for three different cards I have, and I thought others on this list might be interested in the results. All tests were conducted on a dual 2.8 xeon, with a gig of RAM. The cards are a 9600AS with 256 megs of RAM, a 9000Pro with 129 megs of RAM, and an X700 with 256 megs. After each test with the DRI drivers, I rebooted and ran the exact same one with the FireGL drivers. The DRI drivers are from Mesa (and DRM) CVS from Thursday. The FireGL drivers are the latest available at the moment (I don't remember the version number off the top of my head). There have been no game specific changes made in driconf.
Using "timedemo demo1" in doom3 (640x480, "low quality" settings), this is what I got:
9600 - fgl - 13.4 FPS 9600 - dri - 15 FPS 9000 - fgl - 14 FPS 9000 - dri - 17.6 FPS X700 - fgl - 13.8 FPS X700 - dri - 14.7 FPSUsing umark for benchmarking UT2004 (1024x768 with all "low" or "very low" display settings)... First DM-1on1-Albatross:
9600 - fgl - 11.378239 / 35.393394 / 82.763985 fps - Score = 35.407494 9600 - dri - 5.033368 / 8.846323 / 17.930601 fps - Score = 8.850811 9000 - fgl - 13.003528 / 31.308100 / 93.127403 fps - Score = 31.318676 9000 - dri - 6.515143 / 11.408949 / 22.809250 fps - Score = 11.415204 X700 - fgl - 12.597370 / 43.225315 / 114.483971 fps - Score = 43.069965 X700 - dri - 5.531275 / 9.642255 / 24.157600 fps - Score = 9.647329 DM-Rustorium: 9600 - fgl - 11.864109 / 39.673630 / 107.136818 fps - Score = 39.679264 9600 - dri - .755556 / 9.333500 / 21.820055 fps - Score = 9.336345 9000 - fgl - 13.001156 / 27.800968 / 77.328308 fps - Score = 27.807644 9000 - dri - 7.519938 / 12.948973 / 27.574434 fps - Score = 12.951131 X700 - fgl - 21.063986 / 69.125237 / 155.321548 fps - Score = 65.804871 X700 - dri - 6.243832 / 9.895700 / 32.778217 fps - Score = 9.896439In retrospect, I should have done ut2004 at 640x480 to get a better comparison of how it stacks up to doom3.
Adam ------------------------------------------------------- This SF.Net email is sponsored by xPML, a groundbreaking scripting language that extends applications into web and mobile media. Attend the live webcast and join the prime developer group breaking into this new coding territory! http://sel.as-us.falkag.net/sel?cmd=lnk&kid=110944&bid=241720&dat=121642 -- _______________________________________________ Dri-devel mailing list Dri-devel@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/dri-devel