On 21 Nov 2002 23:15:26 -0500 Robert Wohlfarth <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
wrote:

> On Thu, 2002-11-21 at 00:04, Pierre Fortin wrote:
> > * just enabling modem access resulted in shorewall being silently
> > enabled...  When I tried to switch back to LAN mode, I was unable to
> > connect to ANYTHING...
> 
> The default Shorewall configuration is setup for an ethernet card
> (eth0). It blocks access to everything on ppp0 (the dial up connection).
> This link provides a proper configuration:
> http://shorewall.net/standalone.htm

Thanks -- I'll look at this; but my point to Mandrake is still that this
is a laptop that:
- worked on a LAN
- worked on a dialup
- would not work on a LAN again until I found that shorewall came into the
picture SILENTLY*

* and NO, /var/log/{messages,syslog} does NOT count as notification -- how
many people expect to have networking DISABLED by simply switching from
LAN to dial and back to LAN...????

> Hopefully future Mandrake releases will configure Shorewall during
> install. Wouldn't want dial-up users to give up on Mandrake when there's
> no Internet connection.

My problem was not going to dialup; it was going back to LAN...

BTW, I also got some screen captures of MCC claiming I was connected; yet
there were NO cables hooked up...  The "M" in MCC does not stand for
Linu*s*, RedHat, Suse, etc...

I'm on a tight schedule until the end of Dec; and this did not make me
happy at all...  so sorry if this sounds too harsh; but shorewall shoved
between my back pockets was a tad harsh too, IMO.

Anyway, while I can get around these issues by myself, I hope there will
be more thought given to those who can't if Mdk still intends to target
new users...  

Cheers,
Pierre

Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com

Reply via email to