Peer-Reviewed Study Rocks Climate Debate! 'Nature not man responsible for recent global warming...little or none of late 20th century warming and cooling can be attributed to humans' 'Surge in global temps since 1977 can be attributed to a 1976 climate shift in the Pacific Ocean' Wednesday, July 22, 2009By Marc Morano <http://www.climatedepot.com/contact.asp> Climate Depot <http://www.climatedepot.com> A new peer-reviewed climate study is presenting a head on challenge to man-made global warming claims. The study by three climate researchers appears in the July 23, 2009 edition of Journal of Geophysical Research. (Link to Abstract <http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/2009/2008JD011637.shtml> )
Full Press Release and Abstract to Study: July 23, 2009 Nature not man responsible for recent global warming Three Australasian researchers have shown that natural forces are the dominant influence on climate, in a study just published in the highly-regarded Journal of Geophysical Research. According to this study little or none of the late 20th century global warming and cooling can be attributed to human activity. The research, by Chris de Freitas, a climate scientist at the University of Auckland in New Zealand, John McLean (Melbourne) and Bob Carter (James Cook University), finds that the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is a key indicator of global atmospheric temperatures seven months later. As an additional influence, intermittent volcanic activity injects cooling aerosols into the atmosphere and produces significant cooling. "The surge in global temperatures since 1977 can be attributed to a 1976 climate shift in the Pacific Ocean that made warming El Niño conditions more likely than they were over the previous 30 years and cooling La Niña conditions less likely" says corresponding author de Freitas. "We have shown that internal global climate-system variability accounts for at least 80% of the observed global climate variation over the past half-century. It may even be more if the period of influence of major volcanoes can be more clearly identified and the corresponding data excluded from the analysis." Climate researchers have long been aware that ENSO events influence global temperature, for example causing a high temperature spike in 1998 and a subsequent fall as conditions moved to La Niña. It is also well known that volcanic activity has a cooling influence, and as is well documented by the effects of the 1991 Mount Pinatubo volcanic eruption. The new paper draws these two strands of climate control together and shows, by demonstrating a strong relationship between the Southern Oscillation and lower-atmospheric temperature, that ENSO has been a major temperature influence since continuous measurement of lower-atmospheric temperature first began in 1958. According to the three researchers, ENSO-related warming during El Niño conditions is caused by a stronger Hadley Cell circulation moving warm tropical air into the mid-latitudes. During La Niña conditions the Pacific Ocean is cooler and the Walker circulation, west to east in the upper atmosphere along the equator, dominates. "When climate models failed to retrospectively produce the temperatures since 1950 the modellers added some estimated influences of carbon dioxide to make up the shortfall," says McLean. "The IPCC acknowledges in its 4th Assessment Report that ENSO conditions cannot be predicted more than about 12 months ahead, so the output of climate models that could not predict ENSO conditions were being compared to temperatures during a period that was dominated by those influences. It's no wonder that model outputs have been so inaccurate, and it is clear that future modelling must incorporate the ENSO effect if it is to be meaningful." Bob Carter, one of four scientists who has recently questioned the justification for the proposed Australian emissions trading scheme, says that this paper has significant consequences for public climate policy. "The close relationship between ENSO and global temperature, as described in the paper, leaves little room for any warming driven by human carbon dioxide emissions. The available data indicate that future global temperatures will continue to change primarily in response to ENSO cycling, volcanic activity and solar changes." "Our paper confirms what many scientists already know: which is that no scientific justification exists for emissions regulation, and that, irrespective of the severity of the cuts proposed, ETS will exert no measurable effect on future climate." -- McLean, J. D., C. R. de Freitas, and R. M. Carter (2009), Influence of the Southern Oscillation on tropospheric temperature, Journal of Geophysical Research, 114, D14104, doi:10.1029/2008JD011637. This figure from the McLean et al (2009) research shows that mean monthly global temperature (MSU GTTA) corresponds in general terms with the Southern Oscillation Index (SOI) of seven months earlier. The SOI is a rough indicator of general atmospheric circulation and thus global climate change. The possible influence of the Rabaul volcanic eruption is shown. Excerpted Abstract of the Paper appearing in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Time series for the Southern Oscillation Index (SOI) and global tropospheric temperature anomalies (GTTA) are compared for the 1958-2008 period. GTTA are represented by data from satellite microwave sensing units (MSU) for the period 19802008 and from radiosondes (RATPAC) for 19582008. After the removal from the data set of short periods of temperature perturbation that relate to near-equator volcanic eruption, we use derivatives to document the presence of a 5- to 7-month delayed close relationship between SOI and GTTA. Change in SOI accounts for 72% of the variance in GTTA for the 29-year-long MSU record and 68% of the variance in GTTA for the longer 50-year RATPAC record. Because El Niño-Southern Oscillation is known to exercise a particularly strong influence in the tropics, we also compared the SOI with tropical temperature anomalies between 20°S and 20°N. The results showed that SOI accounted for 81% of the variance in tropospheric temperature anomalies in the tropics. Overall the results suggest that the Southern Oscillation exercises a consistently dominant influence on mean global temperature, with a maximum effect in the tropics, except for periods when equatorial volcanism causes ad hoc cooling. That mean global tropospheric temperature has for the last 50 years fallen and risen in close accord with the SOI of 57 months earlier shows the potential of natural forcing mechanisms to account for most of the temperature variation. Received 16 December 2008; accepted 14 May 2009; published 23 July 2009. [End Abstract Excerpt] Related Links: More Than 700 International Scientists Dissent Over Man-Made Global Warming Claims <http://epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Minority.Blogs&Conten\ tRecord_id=10fe77b0-802a-23ad-4df1-fc38ed4f85e3> Study shakes foundation of climate theory! Reveals UN models 'fundamentally wrong' - Blames 'Unknown Processes' -- not CO2 for ancient global warming <../../a/1955/Study-shakes-foundation-of-climate-theory-Reveals-UN-model\ s-fundamentally-wrong--Blames-Unknown-Processes--not-CO2-for-ancient-glo\ bal-warming> Climate Depot: G8 Leaders embrace 'climate astrology' - Trying to control Earth's thermostat is 'madness of our age' - July 10, 2009 <http://www.onenewsnow.com/Culture/Default.aspx?id=598036> Obama's 'Climate Astrologer': Energy Sec. Chu claims he knows 'what the future will be 100 years from now' -- 'Shouldn't Chu be touting these scary predictions of the year 2100 on a boardwalk with a full deck of Tarot Cards?' - June 28, 2009 <../../a/1723/Flashback-Obamas-Climate-Astrologer-Energy-Sec-Chu-claims-\ he-knows-what-the-future-will-be-100-years-from-now> Canadian Prime Minister Harper: 'There Is Going To Have To Be Some Semblance of Global Governance' - July 10, 2009 <http://www.failedexperiment.com/harpergorepope-call-for-global-governan\ ce/> NASA Warming Scientist Hansen Blasts Obama's 'Counterfeit' Climate Bill - Calls it 'a monstrous absurdity...less than worthless!' - July 9, 2009 <../../a/1875/NASA-Warming-Scientist-Hansen-Blasts-Obamas-Counterfeit-Cl\ imate-Bill--Calls-it-a-monstrous-absurdityless-than-worthless> Gore's claim of 10 year climate 'tipping point' was already made by the UN -- in 1989! <http://epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Minority.Blogs&Conten\ tRecord_id=37AE6E96-802A-23AD-4C8A-EDF6D8150789> Earth's 'Fever' Breaks! Global temperatures 'have plunged .74°F since Gore released An Inconvenient Truth' July 5, 2009 <../../a/1799/Earths-Fever-Breaks-Global-temperatures-have-plunged-74deg\ F-since-Gore-released-An-Inconvenient-Truth> Another Moonwalker Defies Gore: NASA Astronaut Dr. Buzz Aldrin rejects global warming fears: 'Climate has been changing for billions of years' <../../a/1792/Another-Moonwalker-Defies-Gore-NASA-Astronaut-Dr-Buzz-Aldr\ in-rejects-global-warming-fears-Climate-has-been-changing-for-billions-o\ f-years> Climate Depot Report: Gore's path to become the first 'Carbon Billionaire' - May 2, 2009 <../../a/593/VideoTranscript-The-OReilly-Factor-features-Climate-Depot-o\ n-Gores-path-to-become-the-first-Carbon-Billionaire> Climate Depot Factsheet on the 'Gore Effect' Phenomenon July 9, 2009 <../../a/1869/Climate-Depot-Factsheet-on-the-Gore-Effect-Phenomenon> Aussie Geologist: Climate fear is 'new religion for urban populations which have lost their faith in Christianity' Gore a 'prophet' <../../a/1866/Aussie-Geologist-Climate-fear-is-new-religion-for-urban-po\ pulations-which-have-lost-their-faith-in-Christianity> Princeton Physicist: 'The idea that Congress can stop climate change is just hilarious' - Warns of 'climate change cult' July 8, 2009 <../../a/1852/Princeton-Physicist-The-idea-that-Congress-can-stop-climat\ e-change-is-just-hilarious--Warns-of-climate-change-cult> Climate Depot Editorial: Climate bill offers (costly) non-solutions to problems that don't even exist - June 30, 2009 <../../a/1697/Updated-Climate-Depot-Editorial-Climate-bill-offers-costly\ -nonsolutions-to-problems-that-dont-even-exist>
