I am new to Cairngorm and Flex (I'm All About Flash) so bear with me.

I am creating a component and I want it to use Cairngorm. I also want 
to be sure that some events fired from the component are only heard 
by the Cairngorm of the single component instance. Component 
namespaces won't help because I use multiple instances of the same 
event, I could probably filter by instance, but I am trying not to 
hack (you'll probably see the irony after the next sentence...

If I use Cairngorm as is... ...and I utilize the Singleton 
CairngormEventDispatcher, as soon as I put two instances of a 
component on stage, the events from one instance cause the front 
controller on the second instance to fire those events 

Sadly this is probably operator error.

Though I am guessing that someone has had this problem before and 
surely there is a best practice solution to this already, I thought I 
would spend a little time to explore the issue further and find my 
own solution.

I decided to try to handle this by using separate instances of the 
CairngormEventDispatcher (MyViewHelper.dispatcher) for each instance 
of my component. Then I could inject that dispatcher into 
MyFrontController when it is instantiated so that it knows which 
dispatcher to call. 

Just when I think I am on to something, I had to override addCommand 
so that it would add an event listener to that instance instead of 
the Singleton CairngormEventDispatcher. This is great but it required 
two modifications (minor, yet still modifications) to the Cairngorm 
FrontController class in order to compile my creation. (see snippets 
below) Basically I took two private things and made them protected.

Of course this might effect other pieces I have yet to build, but my 
level of mastery coerces me into believing I have found a solid 
answer. <snicker/> If those iteration two guys were really geniuses 
they would have made these protected in the first place. 

Ha, ha, ha, just kidding, (I crack myself up)

So I can either use my own FrontController impl or I can ask the 
question: Is this a bug in Cairngorm? Or am I correct in beleiving I 
must be doing something wrong...

Some code samples:

//
// myViewHelper Snippet:
//
public function MyViewHelper(view:Object)
{
dispatcher = new CairngormEventDispatcher();
controller = new MyFrontController(dispatcher);
...
}

//
// myFrontController Snippet:
//
public class MyFrontController extends FrontController
{

private var dispatcher:CairngormEventDispatcher;

public function MyFrontController(dispatcher:CairngormEventDispatcher)
{
  super();
  this.dispatcher = dispatcher
  ...
}

public override function addCommand( commandName : String, 
commandRef : Class ) : void
{
if( commands[ commandName ] != null )
{
throw new Error( "Command already registered for " + commandName );
}
commands[ commandName ] = commandRef;
dispatcher.addEventListener( commandName, executeCommand );
}
}

//
// Cairngorm FrontController Mods
//
public class FrontController
{
// ST - 03/15/2007 : private var commands : Dictionary = new 
Dictionary();
protected var commands : Dictionary = new Dictionary();

// ST - 03/15/2007 : private function executeCommand( event : 
CairngormEvent ) : void
protected function executeCommand( event : CairngormEvent ) : void

...

}


Reply via email to