I'd like to throw in an optical consideration
on comprehensions for lists vs. monads:

If comprehensions are allowed for arbitrary monads,
then [x] as an expression means "return, in some monad"
while [x] as a type expression means "the list type".

This is a discrepancy. I think it looks confusing
to disambiguate  ['c']  by writing   ['c'] :: [Char].
A naive spectator would say: Clearly 'c' :: Char, 
so why should putting brackets around both sides have any effect?

Regards,
-- 
Johannes Waldmann   Institut fur Informatik   FSU   D-07740  Jena  Germany
http://www5.informatik.uni-jena.de/~joe/ mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]



Reply via email to