[IslamCity] Sunni hadith versus Shia hadith.

[Abdul Wahid Osman Belal]

BR>From: "Aqsa *" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Date: Mon, 30 May 2005 04:19:17 +0000
Subject: Sunni hadith versus Shia hadith.

------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
Would you Help a Child in need?
It is easier than you think.
Click Here to meet a Child you can help.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/sTR6_D/I_qJAA/i1hLAA/TXWolB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->

Assalaamualaikum wa rahmatuallahi wa barakatahu

Sunni hadith versus Shia hadith.
----------------------------------

One of the major differences between Shia and Sunni is in their definition
of Sunnah and Hadith. There is a vital difference in the nature of
acceptable Sunnah for both groups.

The Sunnis accept all the ahadith said to be genuine and reported by any of
the Prophet’s companions.Quran confirms the righteousness of companions of
prophet muhammad peace be upon him.The hadith were written at the time of
prophet and continued to be written in later times as well.Sunnis have
developed a specific method of ‘criticism’ to authenticate the Hadith, which
merged soon after the death of the Prophet.


49:13 O mankind! We created you from a single (pair) of a male and a female
and made you into nations and tribes that ye may know each other (not that
ye may despise each other). Verily the most honored of you in the sight of
Allah is (he who is) the most righteous of you. And Allah has full
knowledge and is well acquainted (with all things).

The science of collecting, analysing, compiling, grading and reporting
of hadiths became a special field of studies after the period of
companions (radiallahu `anhum). The leading reports are from
Al-Bukhari, Muslim, At-Tirmidhi, An-Nasai, Ibn Majah, and Abu Dawood
which are known as the six most authentic books (As-Sihaahus-Sittah).
The validity of a hadith depends solely on its agreement with the
Qur'an and the grading of a hadith depends on the reliability of the
chain of narrators who reported it. In order to do this, the reporter
studied the characters and the life of every single person who were
mentioned in the chain of narrators. We notice that utmost care was
exercised not only in reporting the exact words, but also sifting
through the characters of persons who reported them. If a single
person in the chain of narrators is reported to be of doubtful
character or unreliable, then the entire hadith is either rejected or
this fact is noted down and specifically mentioned.

The Imams who undertook this enormous task of compiling and reporting
the hadiths exercised great care in their lifetime effort, because
these studies laid the foundation for the guidelines in understanding
and practicing Islam in the life of every Muslim.

There are two kinds of Hadith compilations: musannaf and musnad. In musannaf
collections, hadiths are recorded under various headings dealing with
juridical subjects. The most famous musannaf collections are:

1. Sahih Al-Bukhari (d. AH 256/870 CE)

2. Sahih Muslim (d. AH 261/874 CE)

3. Sunan An-Nasa’i (d. AH 303/916 CE)

4. Sunan Abi Dawud (d. AH 275/889 CE)

5. Sunan At-Tirmidhi (d. AH 279/892 CE)

6. Sunan Ibn Majah (d. AH 273/886 CE)

In musnad collections, hadiths are arranged alphabetically under the names
of the Companions on whose authority these hadiths were reported. An example
of this kind is Musnad Ahmad ibn Hanbal (d. AH 241/855 CE).


"The Prophet is closer to the believers than their own selves.." 33:6

so everything thing prophet said we believe.


Quran confirms the righteousness of companions of prophet.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
9:100 The vanguard (of Islam) the first of those who forsook (their homes)
and of those who gave them aid and (also) those who follow them in (all)
good deeds well pleased is Allah with them as are they with him: for them
hath He prepared gardens under which rivers flow to dwell therein for ever:
that is the supreme felicity.


haz ayesha gave many hadith and umm salamah.
33:34 And recite what is rehearsed to you in your homes of the Signs of
Allah and His wisdom: for Allah understands the finest mysteries and is
well-acquainted (with them).

for ansars and helpers
4:33 To (benefit) everyone We have appointed sharers and heirs to property
left by parents and relatives. To those also to whom your right hand was
pledged give their due portion: for truly Allah is Witness to all things.

9:117 Allah turned with favor to the prophet the Muhajirs and the Ansar who
followed Him in a time of distress after that the hearts of a part of them
had nearly swerved (from duty); but He turned to them (also): for He is unto
them Most Kind Most Merciful.

33:6 The Prophet is closer to the Believers than their own selves and his
wives are their mothers. Blood-relations among each other have closer
personal ties in the Decree of Allah than (the Brotherhood of) Believers and
Muhajirs: nevertheless do ye what is just to your closest friends: such is
the writing in the Decree (of Allah).


the charitable companions,
24:22 Let not those among you who are endued with grace and amplitude of
means resolve by oath against helping their kinsmen those in want and those
who have left their homes in Allah's cause: let them forgive and overlook:
do you not wish that Allah should forgive you? For Allah is Oft-Forgiving
Most Merciful.



9:120 It was not fitting for the people of Medina and the bedouin Arabs of
the neighborhood to refuse to follow Allah's Apostle nor to prefer their own
lives to his: because nothing could they suffer or do but was reckoned to
their credit as a deed of righteousness whether they suffered thirst or
fatigue or hunger in the cause of Allah or trod paths to raise the ire of
the unbelievers or received any injury whatever from an enemy: for Allah
suffereth not the reward to be lost of those who do good;
121 Nor could they spend anything (for the cause) small or great nor cut
across a valley but the deed is inscribed to their credit; that Allah might
requite their deed with the best (possible reward).
122 Nor should the believers all go forth together: if a contingent from
every expedition remained behind they could devote themselves to studies in
religion and admonish the people when they return to them that thus they
(may learn) to guard themselves (against evil).

33:21 Ye have indeed in the Apostle of Allah a beautiful pattern of
(conduct) for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Final Day and who
engages much in the praise of Allah.
22 When the Believers saw the Confederate forces they said: "This is what
Allah and His Apostle had promised us and Allah and his Apostle told us what
was true." And it only added to their faith and their zeal in obedience.
23 Among the Believers are men who have been true to their Covenant with
Allah: of them some have completed their vow to (the extreme) and some
(still) wait: but they have never changed (their determination) in the
least:
24 That Allah may reward the men of Truth for their Truth and punish the
Hypocrites if that be His Will or turn to them in Mercy: for Allah is
Oft-Forgiving Most Merciful.

57:10 And what cause have ye why ye should not spend in the cause of Allah?
For to Allah belongs the heritage of the heavens and the earth. Not equal
among you are those who spent (freely) and fought before the Victory (with
those who did so later). Those are higher in rank than those who spent
(freely) and fought afterwards. But to all has Allah promised a goodly
(reward) and Allah is well-acquainted with all that ye do.


48:18 Allah's Good Pleasure was on the believers when they swore Fealty to
thee under the Tree: He knew what was in their hearts and He sent down
tranquillity to them and He rewarded them with a speedy Victory;

Al-Tirmidhi HadithHadith 6093 Narrated byAli ibn AbuTalib
Allah's Messenger (peace be upon him) said to him, "You have a resemblance
to Jesus whom the Jews hated so much that they slandered his mother and whom
the Christians loved so much that they placed him in a position not rightly
his." Ali afterwards said, "Two people will perish on my account, one who
loves me so excessively that he praises me for what I do not possess, and
one who hates me so much that he will be impelled by his hatred to slander
me."
Ahmad transmitted it.

*****************************************

The Shias accept only those ahadith that have been reported by or attributed
to the Ahl al-Bait or direct descendents of the Prophet,or the supporters of
Ali may Allah be pleased with him.Further, Shias include in their Hadith
collections not only statements attributed to the Prophet but also
statements attributed to their Imams, whom they regard as infallible. Unlike
the Sunnis, the Shias, therefore place, in effect, the authenticated sayings
of their Imams on par with the sayings of the Prophet and of Allah as
contained in the Quran.

If a person has heard something directly from the 12 Imams, and that person
is trustworthy for the Shia and his narration is not against Quran, then
the tradition is authentic for shia's, since they believe in the
infallibility of Imams as well as Prophets. The knowledge of Imam has been
derived from the knowledge of their fathers and forefathers up to the
Prophet (PBUH&HF).

INFALLIBILITY OF HUMANS IS NEGATED QURANIC VERSE COZ ALL COMMITED MISTAKES
/SINS

35: 45 If Allah were to punish men according to what they deserve He would
not leave on the back of the (earth) a single living creature: but He gives
them respite for a stated Term: when their Term expires verily Allah has in
his sight all His servants.



However, the chain of narrators should be evaluated. If the chain turns out
to be broken (i.e., one element in the chain is missing), then the
tradition is considered weak in Isnad. Thus all the narrators should be
named, and this is the case for the majority of Shi'i collections of
traditions.


Bukhari, in particular, is a Sunni scholar who compiled the ahadith, thus
forming what we today know as the Sahih Bukhari. The fact is that Shias
do not reject Bukhari. There are many ahadith in Sahih Bukhari that have
been accepted by Shias, but Shias do not hold that whatever is in Sahih
Bukhari is always true. For that reason, shia's also do not accept
everything
that is contained in Bihar-ul-Anwar, a book in which Allama Majlisi has
compiled all the ahadith!!


Comprehensive Hadith Collection

The title "The Comprehensine Collection" refers to there hadith books by
which the scholar is more or less not so much in need of cheking other
hadith sources. In the Shiite hadith scholarship, this Collection Consists
of the following:

1. Ghurar al – Hikam
2. Al – Kafi
3. Al – tahdib
4. Man la Yahdruhu al – Faqih
5. Mustadrak al – Wasail
6. Bihar al – Anwar
7. Jami Ahadith al – Shie



AL-KAFI

Here we have Usool al- Kafi that is a collection narrations and traditions
attributed to the Shiite Imams, Ahlul Bayt and the Prophet. Al-Kafi is the
MOST reliable Shia Book, as the reliable Shia Scholars said and declared .
Its author is Thiqat al-Islam Muhamad Ibn Yaqoob AlKulayni (A VERY reliable
Shia Scholar, died in 328 H). Some Shi'ites scholars believe usool Al-Kafi
was presented to the legendary Imam Qaem who liked it and said: "It suffices
our Shi'ites" (al-Tharee'ah ela Tasaneef al-Shi'a: Agha Buzurg al-Tahraani;
vol.17, p.245)

Al-Kafi is a collection of Hadiths attributed to the prophet Muhamad p.b.u.h
and The Infallible Imams -according to Shia- and like AhlSunnah, who give
much importance to their Hadith book (Saheeh AlBukhari), Shia give the same
or maybe even more importance to their Book (Al-Kafi) . Unlike AhlSunnah who
call AlBukhari's Book as (Saheeh AlBukhari), Shia do not call Al-Kafi as
(Saheeh Al-Kafi), nevertheless, Shia treat Al-Kafi as it is (Saheeh) and
their most reliable scholars declare it as a (Saheeh) .

Ironically we find Mr. Mulla Baqir Majlisi stating in his commentary on
al-Kafi, named Mir'at al-'Uqul, that 9,485 out of the 16,121 narrations in
al-Kafi are unreliable! Now here we reach two conclusions, either Imam Qaem
made a mistake to authenticate a book, 60% of whose contents would later be
discovered to be unreliable or Mr. Mulla Baqir Majlisi (the most reliable
and respected Shia Scholars ever existed) did not know what he was talking
about.



On the other hand, the collection of Hadiths available with the Shias does
not appear to have undergone the same sort of rigorous critical examination
as is the case with Sunnis.
It should be made clear straightaway that the juristic differences among the
Sunni schools of thought are not similar to the differences between Shias
and Sunnis. The differences among the four major Sunni schools of
jurisprudence are not in matters of faith (aqidah), and hence do not
constitute a fundamental difference unlike that between Sunnis as a whole
and the Shias.


Wallahu alam
Aqsa.

_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/


17:81"And say, Truth has (now) arrived, and falsehood perished: For falsehood is (by its nature) bound to perish."

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HadithAndSunnah/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/