This thread reminds me of what my music theory professor once told me about composition: "If it sounds good, it's good."
Given that no two lutes and no two lutenists are the same, it is entirely possible that what works for one player on their instrument may not work for a different player on their instrument. Plus, there is the difference between playing for yourself or family in a small room, and trying to be heard solo or amongst other instruments in a large space. As Mace says, one may have to sacrifice "sweetness" for projection - nails and plectra probably producing more high frequencies and "white noise" which carry farther, provide articulation, and are more easily heard. There is also the matter of personal taste: what sounds good to me may not sound good to another. There can be more than one "correct" way to do anything. One person's trash is another's treasure. Personally, I am always my own worst critic and am still working on getting results that please me on my lute instead of "hellish, jarring sounds." Thanks everybody for all of your insights. It's good to be able to learn form others' knowledge and experience. All the best, Tom Date sent: Fri, 13 Dec 2013 15:10:03 +0000 From: "Braig, Eugene" <brai...@osu.edu> However, once again, Mace offers this advice in acknowledging the antecedent: "strike . . . your strings with your nails, as some do, who maintain it the best way to play." Mace's implication is that nail play was also commonplace and that tastes on this topic varied. Eugene -----Original Message----- From: lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu [mailto:lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu] On Behalf Of Bruno Correia Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2013 9:40 PM To: List LUTELIST Subject: [LUTE] Mace The reason, why the nails are not so good to draw sounds with, as the flesh. But on doing of this, take notice, that you strike not your strings with your nails, as some do, who maintain it the best way to play, but I do not; and for this reason; because the nail cannot draw so sweet a sound from a lute, as the nibble end of the flesh can do. I confess in a consort, it might do well enough, where the mellowness (which is the most excellent satisfaction from a lute) is lost in the crowd; but alone, I could never receive so good content from the nail, as from the flesh; (however, this being my opinion) let others do, what seems best to themselves. Thomas Mace (London, 1676). Pretty good advice from the English master. -- Bruno Figueiredo Pesquisador autonomo da pratica e interpretac,ao historicamente informada no alaude e teorba. Doutor em Praticas Interpretativas pela Universidade Federal do Estado do Rio de Janeiro. -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html Tom Draughon Heartistry Music http://www.heartistrymusic.com/artists_tom.html 714 9th Avenue West Ashland, WI 54806 715-682-9362 --