>David Bridson wrote:
>
>> >That seems to be the world upside down. Adapting an encoder in
order
>> >to fit a non-mp3-compliant player is no good move I think. Best is
to
>> >contact the mpg123 author?
>>
>> I don't think it's just mpg123 - I have problems playing same file
in
>> CL-Amp under BeOS with VBR MP3s and CRC.
>
>CL-Amp has both a mpg123-based and an amp-based plugin, if memory
serves
>me right. Maybe you're using the mpg123-based one?
Well, since i'm currently surfing, I thought i'd dig out my CD of
"Surfin'" and
check this out. I've tried both the mpg123 and amp versions (note: the
amp
plugin is not included with CL-Amp, only as a separate download) of the
MP3
plugin. "Surfin'" with CRC plays about 0.5 seconds of squeaks using the
mpg123
plugin and the correct length of noise (like an untuned Radio) using
the Amp
plugin. Without CRC, both plugins play correctly.
Is this down to a bug in LAME or a bug in both of the plugins? I'll
contact
the authors personally if the latter is the case.
David
--
MP3 ENCODER mailing list ( http://geek.rcc.se/mp3encoder/ )
