I agree with Julia on the idiosyncratic nature of the Kielder Jock ms. Note that the title and composer have been supplied by another hand. The version of Barrington is one musician's rendering, and valuable as such, but I don't think it improves on the 'original', which is what the Fenwick Tutor version appears to be. The other tunes Fenwick included show him - imho - to be in touch with the core repertoire of the smallpiping tradition, presumably from the best players of the time, e.g. his Holey Ha'penny is the Clough version, simplified but with all the essentials. --
To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
