On Thu, 2010-04-15 at 17:53 +0200, colet.patr...@free.fr wrote: > >> Matteo Sisti Sette a écrit : > >>> Frank wrote: > >>> > It's not so much the tool, as it is the skills that makes music > >>> > sound good. > >>> That is true for really good tools. Needless to say that Pd is one of > >>> them. > > sorry, I might going to be rude, > > but I've never heard some music completely made with PureData that really > sound good. > > they are alway little experiments, or false reproductions of things we know > and without the sound. > > like last time someone posted something that sounded like 'psychic warriors > of gaia', but honnestly i'd prefer the original. > > The skill to make music with pd is about rewriting everything, at the end > it's not really the skill of a musician, > > for example in concrete music, who is the musician, Pierre Schaeffer, or > Pierre Henry? > > Pierre Schaeffer has demonstrated that he is a very skilled music scientist, > but he didn't even made a shit that we could hear like a composition.
While I fully disagree with you in all you've said and I know it's silly to talk about someones taste, this sentence: > pd is just a tool for learning dsp, there is no such project that show how pd > is cool to make people moving on the dance floor. is entirely untrue. Roman _______________________________________________ Pd-list@iem.at mailing list UNSUBSCRIBE and account-management -> http://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-list
