-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Am 25.02.2014 12:50, schrieb PHILLIPS M.E.:
> If we are just talking about ISO 2709, the whole family of MARC formats in > general, then you have to remember that UNIMARC and obsolete formats like > UKMARC > have very different requirements. UKMARC and UNIMARC are actually much easier > to > work with than MARC21 because the ISBD punctuation is not carried in the > record > but is generated from the subfield tags. So you don't have to say "give me the > 245 $a and $b but strip / off the end if present" because the slash is not > there. same thing with MARC21: Punctuation regime for the record is governed by Leader pos. 18 ("descriptive cataloging form" which currently gives the choice between mainly "AACR2", "ISBD with punctuation" and "ISBD without punctuation" - and not yet code(s) for "RDA"). Here in Germany there is a strong tradition that cataloguers shall not enter punctuation when the field granularity of the underlying database allows its automatic generation for display or conversion to other formats (what I mean is: punctuation is generated when converting from the internal format to MARC in cases where MARC is not as granular as the internal format). This applies to RAK data in the union databases and its transport via MAB2 or MARC21 and it is also the intention to carry this on when switching from RAK to RDA. [There's also been the regulation for the D-A-CH application layer to move punctuation which cannot be eliminated to the start of the subfield "it belongs to", e.g. 245 $a title = $b parallel title becomes 245 $a title $b = parallel title probably on the prospect that this could ease processing...] viele Gruesse Thomas Berger -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1 Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/ iJwEAQECAAYFAlMMjZ0ACgkQYhMlmJ6W47NLLgP+KJcGwEad9zbYoUNRQer/+XBd L39rvnWDMK6XOmW5NL+M3FQFSfArT2iJ1eyIuni92gLMfURG+z96SrKVQNEcF+IL DVglbTE4+6OqNGf61YcwBA3x/k+MVrmqGKLqoKE7R43FgaYHKk3s7PlYaf1au9mz z9nNz/hZDEXmujNIxJ8= =uVi7 -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----