Don Charuk wrote:
[snip]
If the author is provided on the title page and the illustrator is provide on 
the title page verso can they both be transcribe in the statement of the 
responsibility? Does not the rule 2.4.2.2 state the SOR should come from the 
same source as the title proper. If so interpreted, would/could you not make a 
note for the illustrator according to rule 2.20.3? 

-------------------------------------------------

It was not my understanding (from various training sources) that 2.4.2.2 
required the SOR to come from the same source as the title proper.  Instead, 
2.4.2.2 offers three options as the source of the SOR, and lists them in order 
of preference.  It does not state that in selecting one option that the others 
are precluded, which is to say, there is no RDA equivalent to AACR2's "chief 
source."  Given that, one may mix-and-match sources to most fully describe the 
resource in hand?  (Remaining mindful that extending the description beyond the 
CORE elements is a matter of cataloger judgment.)

John F. Myers, Catalog Librarian
Schaffer Library, Union College
Schenectady NY 12308

mye...@union.edu
518-388-6623

Reply via email to