OFF: [Referee] Infraction Reaction
On Sun, 2023-07-16 at 18:01 -0700, 4st nomic via agora-business wrote: > On Sun, Jul 9, 2023 at 3:11 PM 4st nomic via agora-business < > agora-busin...@agoranomic.org> wrote: > > CoE: This is ratified, however, I still submit the CoE that "Secure > > Contain Protect" is not in the proposal pool or otherwise voted > > upon. > > Referee!! > I note an infraction for violating rule 2201: > The Promotor failed to respond to this CoE in a timely manner. A close reading of rule 2201 discovers that the duty to respond to a CoE depends not on whether or not the original document is self- ratifying, but rather on whether its publisher was required to publish it. There is some inclarity as to specifically which document 4st was doubting; e quoted a proposal distribution and the Promotor's proposal pool report. The latter is part of the Promotor's weekly report (rule 1607), and therefore the Promotor is required to publish it (rule 2143); the former is required if the proposal was in the proposal pool at the start of the week. Proposal 9002, the proposal being distributed, was added to the proposal pool on Monday June 19, within the same week, and as such the Promotor had not yet incurred a requirement to publish the distribution of proposal 9002. This means that 4st's action, of issuing a doubt in a document, failed; rule 2201 requires the action of doubting a document to "identify a document", among other things. Neither eir statement "in the proposal pool or otherwise voted on", nor eir quote, unambiguously defines a specific document, and so eir action of doubting is likely to have failed due to ambiguity; the details of which document was being identified matter, because it affects whether the Promotor has a duty to respond. Even with the possible interpretation of "the doubted document is the entire message", not everything within that message was required to be published, and thus there is no SHALL-duty for its author to respond to a CoE on the message as a whole. As such, I believe that there was no infraction committed, and thus it was not possible to note it. To be more precise: I cannot establish by a preponderance of the evidence that the infraction was committed (rule 2531(1)), and as such, even if the infraction did occur (and thus was noted), it would be automatically forgiven and I would thus be unable to investigate it. -- ais523 Referee
OFF: [Promotor] Proposal Pool
PROMOTOR'S REPORT AS OF RIGHT NOW The proposal pool is currently empty. -- snail
OFF: [Collector] Stamp Collections (16 July 2023)
Stamp Holdings as of 16 Jul 2023 -- Stamp Holdings -- L (18): - 1 Aced7 stamp - 2 ais523 stamps - 1 Madrid stamp - 1 Marb stamp - 5 nix stamps - 5 R. Lee stamps - 1 Shy Owl stamp - 1 tb148 stamp - 1 Yachay stamp ais523 (52): - 1 4st stamp - 28 ais523 stamps - 1 Janet stamp - 1 juan stamp - 15 Madrid stamps - 1 Murphy stamp - 3 nix stamp - 1 snail stamp - 1 Yachay stamp Anneke (1): - 1 Anneke stamp Aspen (48): - 48 Aspen stamps beokirby (1): - 1 beokirby stamp blob (1): - 1 blob stamp Janet (13): - 6 ais523 stamps - 2 Janet stamp - 1 Madrid stamp - 1 orb stamp - 1 Pilgore stamp - 1 snail stamp - 1 ziproot stamp juan (12): - 2 ais523 stamps - 7 juan stamps - 1 Madrid stamp - 1 Murphy stamp - 1 snail stamp Katie (13): - 12 Katie stamps - 1 Yachay stamp Murphy (2): - 2 Murphy stamps snail (12): - 1 snail stamp - 1 juan stamp - 3 nix stamp - 5 R. Lee stamps - 2 Yachay stamps Yachay Wayllukuq (1): - 1 Yachay stamps All other stamp balances are 0. --- Type Totals --- 4st: 1 Aced7: 1 Anneke: 1 ais523: 38 Aspen: 48 beokirby: 1 blob: 1 Janet: 3 juan: 9 Katie: 12 Madrid: 18 Marb: 1 Murphy: 4 nix: 11 orb: 1 Pilgore: 1 R. Lee: 10 Shy Owl: 1 snail: 4 tb148: 1 Yachay Wayllukuq: 6 ziproot: 1 Stamp Descriptions (does not ratify) juan Stamps: "It features me in a thoughtful pose, a chalkboard full of indeciphrable mathematical symbols as a background." Madrid Stamp: That image, you know the one. 4st Stamp: "Intricately detailed, innumerous qualities, nothing like it shall ever come to exist. Unless, of course, the original were to be destroyed." - Since Last Report - 2023-07-10: snail transferred 1 R. Lee and 1 nix stamp from L (Charity Dream) 2023-07-10: Katie granted 1 Katie stamp (Wealth Dream) 2023-07-16: Janet granted 1 Janet stamp (Minty Stone) -- snail
OFF: [Dream Keeper] Dream Journal (16 Jul 2023)
Dream Keeper's Weekly Report 16 Jul 2023 Dream Switches (self-ratifies) Charity: snail Justice: Sharing: Murphy Wealth: Katie Machinery: Gardens: ais523 beokirby juan Power: G. Aspen 4st Janet Revolution: Wandering (default): All other active players [Inactive/nonplayers do not have this switch] Explanation of Dreams Charity: Get 1 stamp the L has the most of, or more if 11+ or 21+ stamps. Justice: 1 blot is expunged from you, and if not, you can expunge someone else Sharing: Get X/Y radiance, X is 1/2 of active players, Y is those w/ this dream Wealth: Gain 2/1/0 stamps of your own type if <8/<16/>15 of your stamps exist Machinery: You can flip the device on or off with Agoran Consent. You can act on behalf of the device to take a specified action with 1 support. Gardens: Your base rockiness is increased by 1 after the wandering occurs. Power: Your voting strength on ordinary proposals is increased by 2 while having this dream. Revolution: If less than a majority of dreams, lose 1 point. If a majority, all scores are set to 100-(current score). Wandering (default): No effect. You can envision any dream at any time. Dreams switch to each active player's most recently envisioned dream at the start of each week. Most effects happen afterwards. -- snail
OFF: [Stonemason] Billboard Rock Chart - 16 Jul 2023
THE BILLBOARD ROCK CHART (STONEMASON'S WEEKLY REPORT) StoneMossiness OwnerLast Wielded Immune? --- - --- --- Power0 Agora2023-06-11Agora Soul 0 juan 2023-04-23 Sabotage 0 Agora2023-05-21Agora Minty0 Janet2023-07-16 Protection 0 Agora2023-05-07Agora Recursion0 Agora2023-06-04Agora Hot Potato 0 Agora2023-04-23Agora Blank2 snail2023-05-28 Anti-Equatorial 1 ais523 2023-05-28 Radiance 0 Agora2023-06-25Agora PlayerBase Rockiness -- Beokirby 6 ais523 3 juan 2 Player Reached For Time - --- --- juan Radiance 2023-07-10 21:35:51 Janet Power2023-07-16 21:21:31 Summary of stone functions: PowerA specified player's strength is increased by 3 on referenda on ordinary proposals in their voting period. Soul A specified non-immune stone is stolen by the wielder, then the Soul Stone is transferred to the robbed player. Sabotage The AI of a specified AI-majority decision is increased by 1. MintyA specified player gains a stamp of eir own type. Protection A specified stone becomes immune (until the next Collection Notice). RecursionCan be wielded as any other stone. Hot Potato Grants he wielder 8 radiance, then is transferred to another player. BlankDoes nothing. Anti-Equatorial Steals the mossiest stone, then increases its own mossiness by one. ScoreA specified player's radiance is increased by 3. History: === 2023-07-16 21:21:31 Janet reaches for Power Stone. 2023-07-16 21:21:31 Janet wields Minty Stone, specifying self. 2023-07-10 21:35:51 juan reaches for Radiance Stone. 2023-07-10 00:00:00 Base Rockiness of ais523, Beokirby, juan increased by 1 due to Dream of Gardens. 2023-07-10 00:00:00 Janet gathers Minty Stone, resetting eir Base Rockiness and the stone's mossiness. 2023-07-09 19:24:06 Janet reaches for Minty Stone. 2023-07-09 18:16:57 Yachay Wayllukuq ceases to have a Base Rockiness switch after the adoption of P9002. 2023-07-03 18:10:11 juan reaches for Radiance Stone. 2023-07-03 00:00:00 Base Rockiness of ais523, Beokirby, Janet, juan increased by 1 due to Dream of Gardens. 2023-07-03 00:00:00 juan gathers Soul Stone, resetting eir Base Rockiness and the stone's mossiness. 2023-07-02 06:06:26 4st reaches for Sabotage Stone. 2023-07-02 05:41:03 Janet reaches for Recursion Stone. 2023-07-02 05:35:48 Mossiness of Soul, Blank, Anti-Equatorial Stones incremented per collection notice. 2023-07-02 05:35:48 Power, Protection, Sabotage, Minty, Radiance, Recursion, Hot Potato stones are transferred to Agora per collection notice, resetting mossiness. 2023-07-02 05:35:48 Collection notice. 2023-06-26 16:06:34 juan reaches for Soul Stone. 2023-06-26 00:00:00 Base Rockiness of ais523, Beokirby, Janet, juan increased by 1 due to Dream of Gardens. 2023-06-26 00:00:00 ais523 gathers Protection Stone, resetting eir Base Rockiness and the stone's mossiness. 2023-06-25 22:38:37 [Janet attempts to reach for Soul Stone.] 2023-06-25 14:40:09 snail reaches for Soul Stone. 2023-06-25 14:40:09 snail wields Radiance Stone, specifying self. 2023-06-25 14:40:09 snail wields Minty Stone, specifying self. 2023-06-19 15:14:08 juan reaches for Soul Stone. 2023-06-19 14:35:44 ais523 reaches for Protection Stone. 2023-06-19 13:08:45 Janet reaches for Soul Stone. 2023-06-19 00:00:00 Base Rockiness of ais523, Beokirby, juan increased by 1 due to Dream of Gardens. 2023-06-19 00:00:00 juan gathers Hot Potato Stone, resetting eir Base Rockiness and the stone's mossiness. 2023-06-13 12:48:32 nix deregisters, resulting in Soul Stone being transferred to Agora. 2023-06-12 12:44:18 juan reaches for Hot Potato Stone. 2023-06-12 12:38:28 ais523 reaches for Protection Stone. 2023-06-12 00:00:00 Base Rockiness of ais523, Beokirby, juan increased by 1 due to Dream of Gardens. 2023-06-12 00:00:00 snail gathers Minty Stone, resetting eir Base Rockiness and the stone's mossiness. 2023-06-11 19:31:08 ais523 wields Power Stone, specifying self. 2023-06-11 19:21:43 snail wields Radiance Stone, specifying self. 2023-06-11 19:21:43 snail reaches for Minty Stone. 2023-06-06 11:38:03 [juan attempts to reach for Anti-Equatorial Stone.] 2023-06-05 00:05:43 Janet reaches for Minty Stone.
OFF: [ADoP] Resolving Rulekeepor election
I resolve the Rulekeepor election as follows: Voting was extended by a week due to lack of quorum (3), which has since been met. 4st, Anneke-Constantine, Aspen, Gaelan, ais523, beokirby, blob, cuddlybanana, innalienableWright, juan, snail, Yachay, omd, and self: You know what you did, or more accurately what you didn't do. Go stand in any one of the square room's five corners. Janet is unanimously elected (votes from emself, G., and Murphy).
OFF: [ADoP] Metareport
=Metareport= You can find an up-to-date version of this report at http://zenith.homelinux.net/adop/report.php Date of last report: 2023-07-09 Date of this report: 2023-07-15 MISCELLANEOUS INFO Filled offices: 18/19 (94.74%) Total officers: 8 Consolidation[1]: 2.25 Late reports: 1/15 (6.67%) [1] This is the number of filled offices divided by the number of officers. At 1, this means that all offices are filled by different players; if it reached the number of filled offices, that would mean that all offices are filled by one player. OFFICES Office Holder[1]Since Last Election Complexity Absurdor juan 2023-06-19(never) 0 ADoP Murphy 2020-07-032023-07-091 Arbitor~ G. 2022-10-092023-01-152 Assessor Janet2019-07-092023-05-073 Buttonmastor juan 2023-06-19(never) 1 Collector *snail2023-04-25(never) 1 Distributor omd 2018-06-15(never)[3]0 Dream Keeper snail2022-12-11(never) 1 Herald *4st 2023-05-252023-05-072 Notary ~ snail2022-03-142023-01-152 Prime Minister ais523 2023-07-092023-07-090 Promotor ~ snail2022-05-012023-01-153 Referee ais523 2023-06-132023-07-092 Registrarjuan 2022-08-292023-07-091 Rulekeepor ~ Janet2019-12-06(ongoing) 3 Speaker G. 2023-06-232019-11-05 [3]0 Stonemason Janet2020-11-11(never) 1 Tailor Murphy 2021-02-282023-07-091 Webmastor *(vacant) 2023-06-13[2] 2023-06-251 [1] * = Interim office (vacant or holder not elected) ~ = Term limited (held for 180+ days, 90+ for Prime Minister) [2] Vacant since this date [3] Currently imposed WEEKLY REPORTS Office ReportLast Published Late[1] Absurdor Boulder Height2023-07-10 ADoP Offices 2023-07-09[2] Arbitor Judicial matters 2023-07-14 Buttonmastor Button time, classes 2023-07-10 CollectorStamps2023-07-09 Dream Keeper Dreams2023-07-09 Herald Radiance 2023-07-15 Promotor Proposal pool 2023-07-09 Referee Rule violations 2023-07-15 RegistrarPlayers, Fora 2023-07-10 Rulekeepor Short Logical Ruleset 2023-07-09 Stonemason Stones2023-07-09 [1] ! = 1 period missed, !! = 2, !!! = 3+ (does not take succumbing into account) [2] Not including this report MONTHLY REPORTS Office ReportLast Published Late Herald Patent titles 2023-07-02 Notary Contracts 2023-06-05 RegistrarPlayer history2023-07-03 Rulekeepor Full Logical Ruleset 2023-06-25 Tailor Ribbons, Laudability 2023-07-02 WebmastorWeb resources 2023-04-02 (vacant) ELECTIONS Office Initiated Phase Candidates Rulekeepor 2023-07-02 Voting 4st, Janet UPCOMING ELECTIONS[1] Office Days Until Last Election Arbitor 00 Days 2023-01-15 Notary 00 Days 2023-01-15 Promotor 00 Days 2023-01-15 Assessor 20 Days 2023-05-07 Herald 20 Days 2023-05-07 [1] Anyone can start an election (with 2 support and also becoming a candidate) 90 days after the previous one (or if it's interim and no election is ongoing). This section shows the 5 elected offices with the most time passed since the last election. Once a quarter, the ADoP SHALL start an
