Orphaning cantus3 [was: Re: Upcoming removals]

2005-05-19 Thread Igor Stroh
Martin Michlmayr wrote:
* Igor Stroh [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2005-05-06 22:10]:
From what I can tell, cantus3 doesn't actually provide all of the
functionality originally present in cantus.
And it won't either -- the upstream is unresponsive and seems to
have no interest neither in incorporating bug fixes nor in adding
features which the package formerly claimed to be offering[0].

I'd suggest to remove cantus3 from the archive if it wouldn't
have so many users (according to popcon.d.o) - there are better

Has there been any agreement about what to do with cantus and cantus3?
Since you're the maintainer of cantus3 and you suggest it's removal,
can you go ahead and file a bug report on ftp.d.o?
I don't like the idea of removing cantus3 right away, maybe there's 
someone who's actually using it and is willing to take over its' 
maintenance.

Anyone up to adopt it?
If nobody speaks up, I'll request a removal.
 Should cantus be removed too?
Yes, imho it's outdated. I'll file a bug report against ftp.d.o.
Cheers,
Igor
--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]


Re: Orphaning cantus3 [was: Re: Upcoming removals]

2005-05-19 Thread Martin Michlmayr
* Igor Stroh [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2005-05-20 01:18]:
 Has there been any agreement about what to do with cantus and cantus3?
 Since you're the maintainer of cantus3 and you suggest it's removal,
 can you go ahead and file a bug report on ftp.d.o?
 
 I don't like the idea of removing cantus3 right away, maybe there's 
 someone who's actually using it and is willing to take over its' 
 maintenance.

Maybe it should be removed from sarge but stay in unstable for now?

  Should cantus be removed too?
 Yes, imho it's outdated. I'll file a bug report against ftp.d.o.

No, reassign the existing WNPP bug to ftp.d.o.
-- 
Martin Michlmayr
http://www.cyrius.com/


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]