R: Re: Proposal: How we should handle committer vetos and reverts in the future

2013-02-14 Thread Pedro Giffuni
Ugh...
I think this is beating the dead horse now, but you cannot say I was 
unresponsive during this thread.

The main question to rescue here is: How decides if a veto is valid or not?

Kay#39;s veto really needed clarification and I still think that your original 
veto was not technical.

Pedro.

Re: R: Re: Proposal: How we should handle committer vetos and reverts in the future

2013-02-14 Thread Joe Schaefer
The PMC decides whether or not an expressed
veto is valid or not.  But generally speaking,
vetos should not be either thrown around willy-
nilly nor should they be challenged every time
they are issued.

It's all part of how we work, this recent episode
should be considered a learning experience not a
model for future work together.






 From: Pedro Giffuni p...@apache.org
To: dev@openoffice.apache.org 
Sent: Thursday, February 14, 2013 10:46 PM
Subject: R: Re: Proposal: How we should handle committer vetos and reverts in 
the future
 
Ugh...
I think this is beating the dead horse now, but you cannot say I was 
unresponsive during this thread.

The main question to rescue here is: How decides if a veto is valid or not?

Kay's veto really needed clarification and I still think that your original 
veto was not technical.

Pedro.