Re: pdf export option for FilterData and ExportFormFields

2013-02-16 Thread Andrea Pescetti

On 12/02/2013 Peter Eberlein wrote:

Am 05.02.2013 22:34, schrieb Andrea Pescetti:

Do you mean that not only you wish that OpenOffice export fields as
enterable fields (which it already does) but that the PDF file
produced by OpenOffice should also support the ability to save form
content? But is this ability a document property or something that
depends on the PDF reader being used?

Yes, I mean the ability to save the content of form fields. ...
It's a document property and doesn't depend on the reader.


I had a look. Actually it is more complex, i.e., as it happens for other 
document properties, readers have different behavior in obeying or 
ignoring restrictions.


I created a simple form (using the Form Controls toolbar) with 
OpenOffice 3.4.1. Then I opened it using Evince, and I was able to save 
the filled-out form with no problems; from the link you sent, it seems 
that the same would happen if one uses FoxIt Reader. But then I tried to 
open it with Adobe Reader (9.5.3) and indeed it didn't allow me to save 
the form.


So I opened an enhancement issue to see whether we may make Adobe Reader 
happy:

https://issues.apache.org/ooo/show_bug.cgi?id=121782
Note that the general issue was already extensively discussed in
https://issues.apache.org/ooo/show_bug.cgi?id=73696
but it's a discussion from over 6 years ago and many details do not 
apply any longer.


Regards,
  Andrea.


Re: pdf export option for FilterData and ExportFormFields

2013-02-12 Thread Peter Eberlein

Hi Andrea,

Am 05.02.2013 22:34, schrieb Andrea Pescetti:


Do you mean that not only you wish that OpenOffice export fields as
enterable fields (which it already does) but that the PDF file
produced by OpenOffice should also support the ability to save form
content? But is this ability a document property or something that
depends on the PDF reader being used?

Yes, I mean the ability to save the content of form fields. And as I see 
now here [1], it doesn't seem to be a legal issue of AdobeĀ®.

It's a document property and doesn't depend on the reader.

Regards

Peter

[1] 
http://www.foxitsoftware.com/company/press.php?action=viewpage=20080508aw3E.html


Re: pdf export option for FilterData and ExportFormFields

2013-02-05 Thread Andrea Pescetti

On 01/02/2013 Dennis E. Hamilton wrote:

FEATURE REQUEST
OpenOffice Writer documents that contain enterable fields should reflect
those fields as enterable when exported as PDF when the level of PDF is one
in which provision of field entries is allowed and has been selected in the
PDF export options.


I don't think the original poster meant this. This is a functionality we 
already have (at least, form controls are exported as enterable 
fields). The request was:



From: Peter Eberlein
Adobe products support an extended feature, so that Acrobat Reader can
store the content of filled fields in forms.


Do you mean that not only you wish that OpenOffice export fields as 
enterable fields (which it already does) but that the PDF file 
produced by OpenOffice should also support the ability to save form 
content? But is this ability a document property or something that 
depends on the PDF reader being used?


Regards,
  Andrea.


pdf export option for FilterData and ExportFormFields

2013-02-01 Thread Peter Eberlein

Hi,
Adobe products support an extended feature, so that Acrobat Reader can 
store the content of filled fields in forms.

Is supporting this feature in openoffice a legal or a technical issue?
Supported features see [1].

Regards Peter

[1] http://wiki.openoffice.org/wiki/API/Tutorials/PDF_export