Re: [Finale] Registration codes and copyright

2003-08-14 Thread Patrick Lenneau
And so it came to pass that On Friday, August 8, 2003, at 02:41  PM, 
Tobias Giesen spake:

b) as Benjamin pointed out, making your product unusable
   by refusing activation codes at some point in the future
   is illegal in the States as well as in Europe.
They wont need to do this to get the same result since copy protection 
software is amongst the most fragile in existence. All it takes is an 
OS upgrade, when Finale 2004 is no longer the current version, which 
causes the copy protection software to break. The then current version 
of Finale will have its copy protection software upgraded to work with 
the OS upgrade but 2004 users will be out of luck.

It is therefore crystal clear that neither Microsoft nor Coda will stop
handing out activation codes for obsolete products, ever.
Activation codes are of no use once the copy protection software is 
incompatible with your current operating system. Youll need a museum 
to make use of them.

Someone mentioned a Mac/PC take on copy protection and Id only point 
out that Mac OSX users have had quite a few reasons to upgrade their OS 
recently and this will likely continue for the foreseeable future. One 
would imagine

Tyranny,
PTL
___
Finale mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mail.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale


Re: [Finale] Registration codes and copyright

2003-08-11 Thread J. Simon van der Walt

 From: Patrick Lenneau [EMAIL PROTECTED]

 copy protection 
 software is amongst the most fragile in existence.

Rather sweeping statement, isn't it?

 Someone mentioned a Mac/PC take on copy protection and I’d only point
 out that Mac OSX users have had quite a few reasons to upgrade their OS
 recently and this will likely continue for the foreseeable future. One
 would imagine

Well, I've updated my mac OS several times over the last couple of years and
never had any problems with any of the dongles/challenge response
codes/serial number of any of my software, beyond having to keep a note of
the necessary numbers (common sense) and re-enter some of them.

The biggest move was from OS9-OSX, and the registration I was most worried
about was Sibelius. OK, I guess I was in the fortunate position of having
another computer handy; I transferred saving from the machine to be upgraded
to a copy of Sib on a 'spare' machine, did the OS upgrade, and transferred
the saving back again. Which is the recommended procedure; no problems.

Considering all the other headaches involved in a big OS move like this
(backing up gigs of data on external drives, reformatting disks, moving data
back, reinstalling new versions of old software, customisation, getting
hardware working again...) I'd say copy protection was the least of my
problems.

On the windoze machines at work, automatic network upgrades get installed
all the time (sometimes in the middle of a bloody lesson, grr), and none of
the copy protection has broken because of it.

-- 
J. Simon van der Walt- Composer
http://www.jsimonvanderwalt.com



___
Finale mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mail.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale