[gentoo-user] 2007.0 CD - 2008.0 install

2008-05-02 Thread Mark Knecht
Before I waste a lot of time I just noticed that I'm using a 2007.0
install CD but downloading and setting up a 2008.0 beta2 system. Is
there any problem building the 2008.0 system files using whatever I
get when I chroot into the new installation?

At this moment I'm doing the tar xjf portage-latest step and noticed
the inconsistency. Apparently all the 2007.0 snapshots, etc., are now
gone from the servers.

Thanks,
Mark
-- 
gentoo-user@lists.gentoo.org mailing list



Re: [gentoo-user] 2007.0 CD - 2008.0 install

2008-05-02 Thread Alan McKinnon
On Friday 02 May 2008, Mark Knecht wrote:
 Before I waste a lot of time I just noticed that I'm using a 2007.0
 install CD but downloading and setting up a 2008.0 beta2 system. Is
 there any problem building the 2008.0 system files using whatever I
 get when I chroot into the new installation?

 At this moment I'm doing the tar xjf portage-latest step and noticed
 the inconsistency. Apparently all the 2007.0 snapshots, etc., are now
 gone from the servers.

There shouldn't be a problem. Aside from the fact that a LiveCD is quite 
a complex thing, as far as installation goes it's sole purpose is to 
provide an environment where you can unpack a stage3 and chroot into 
it.

When you have chrooted, you are essentially in a self-contained 
environment and all that is left of the original environment is the 
kernel it provides. The build system is provided entirely by the chroot 
and nothing in user space can come from or be influenced by what's 
outside it (this is the entire point of chroot).

As long as 2008.0 beta2 can work nicely with the kernel on 2007.0 
LiveCD, it must work exactly as designed. It's hard to imagine a way 
this wouldn't be the case.


-- 
Alan McKinnon
alan dot mckinnon at gmail dot com

-- 
gentoo-user@lists.gentoo.org mailing list



Re: [gentoo-user] 2007.0 CD - 2008.0 install

2008-05-02 Thread Uwe Thiem
On Friday 02 May 2008, Alan McKinnon wrote:
 On Friday 02 May 2008, Mark Knecht wrote:
  Before I waste a lot of time I just noticed that I'm using a
  2007.0 install CD but downloading and setting up a 2008.0 beta2
  system. Is there any problem building the 2008.0 system files
  using whatever I get when I chroot into the new installation?
 
  At this moment I'm doing the tar xjf portage-latest step and
  noticed the inconsistency. Apparently all the 2007.0 snapshots,
  etc., are now gone from the servers.

 There shouldn't be a problem. Aside from the fact that a LiveCD is
 quite a complex thing, as far as installation goes it's sole
 purpose is to provide an environment where you can unpack a stage3
 and chroot into it.

 When you have chrooted, you are essentially in a self-contained
 environment and all that is left of the original environment is the
 kernel it provides. 

Well, plus all running services/daemons unless you take them down 
after chrooting and bring them up again within the chroot.

This can be a life saver. I have my portage tree on box A while box B 
NFS mounts it. At one stage, NFS versions of A and B got so out of 
sync, B couldn't NFS mount /usr/portage any more. A LiveCD with an 
NFS version matching (well, at least fitting) the one on box A was my 
path to salvation. ;-)

 The build system is provided entirely by the 
 chroot and nothing in user space can come from or be influenced by
 what's outside it (this is the entire point of chroot).

This, of course, is absolutely true.

Uwe

-- 
Ignorance killed the cat, sir, curiosity was framed!
-- 
gentoo-user@lists.gentoo.org mailing list



Re: [gentoo-user] 2007.0 CD - 2008.0 install

2008-05-02 Thread Mark Knecht
On Fri, May 2, 2008 at 12:47 PM, Uwe Thiem [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 On Friday 02 May 2008, Alan McKinnon wrote:
   On Friday 02 May 2008, Mark Knecht wrote:
Before I waste a lot of time I just noticed that I'm using a
2007.0 install CD but downloading and setting up a 2008.0 beta2
system. Is there any problem building the 2008.0 system files
using whatever I get when I chroot into the new installation?
   
At this moment I'm doing the tar xjf portage-latest step and
noticed the inconsistency. Apparently all the 2007.0 snapshots,
etc., are now gone from the servers.
  
   There shouldn't be a problem. Aside from the fact that a LiveCD is
   quite a complex thing, as far as installation goes it's sole
   purpose is to provide an environment where you can unpack a stage3
   and chroot into it.
  
   When you have chrooted, you are essentially in a self-contained
   environment and all that is left of the original environment is the
   kernel it provides.

  Well, plus all running services/daemons unless you take them down
  after chrooting and bring them up again within the chroot.

  This can be a life saver. I have my portage tree on box A while box B
  NFS mounts it. At one stage, NFS versions of A and B got so out of
  sync, B couldn't NFS mount /usr/portage any more. A LiveCD with an
  NFS version matching (well, at least fitting) the one on box A was my
  path to salvation. ;-)


   The build system is provided entirely by the
   chroot and nothing in user space can come from or be influenced by
   what's outside it (this is the entire point of chroot).

  This, of course, is absolutely true.

  Uwe


Thanks guys. I've finished the install and attempted to boot. My first
kernel failed at some point I've not run into before complaining about
IO_APIC vectors. I'm searching around in Google for what might have
caused that and building a new kernel in parallel.

The good sign is the machine is starting to show some life. I need to
put the dual boot stuff in grub.conf and make sure Windows is still
booting, and then get this kernel issue worked out.

Thanks for all your inputs today.

Cheers,
Mark
-- 
gentoo-user@lists.gentoo.org mailing list



Re: [gentoo-user] 2007.0 CD - 2008.0 install

2008-05-02 Thread Dirk Heinrichs
Am Freitag, 2. Mai 2008 schrieb Mark Knecht:

 Before I waste a lot of time I just noticed that I'm using a 2007.0
 install CD but downloading and setting up a 2008.0 beta2 system. Is
 there any problem building the 2008.0 system files using whatever I
 get when I chroot into the new installation?

No. You can use what ever LiveCD you like to install Gentoo. Last time, I used 
GRML.

Bye...

Dirk


signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.