Re: [Goanet] A Goa Referendum

2014-09-14 Thread Santosh Helekar
Which political party or mass separatist movement in Goa is demanding such a 
referendum? As far as we know, only a few stray internet characters, all of 
whom are foreign citizens with an anti-India mindset are ranting about this. I 
doubt anybody in Goa takes them seriously.

For comparison see this website of the Quebec separatist party:

http://www.pq.org/

They are demanding a proper referendum to secede from Canada and form their own 
independent country.

There are several separatist parties in Scotland. Here is the website of the 
biggest one of them:

http://www.snp.org/

Contrast this to the situation in Goa. The few foreigners who want separate Goa 
from India will likely be regarded as jokers by most Goans living in Goa today.

Cheers,

Santosh
 


On Saturday, September 13, 2014 9:15 PM, Roland Francis 
roland.fran...@ymail.com wrote:
  Sorry my previous message was sent in error uncompleted.
 
 India needs to correct a historical wrong committed in 1961, by asking the 
 Goan 
 people to determine their own destiny even if it is 53 years later. Goa was 
 not 
 of the Portuguese to give nor of the Indians to take. 
 
 To accept the political and geographical reality, the referendum  should be 
 on 
 the following question:
 
 Should Goa determine its own independent economic future subject to India's 
 defence and foreign affairs control allowing it to enforce its own borders 
 and 
 laws separate from the Indian constitution.
 Yes or no.
 
 The arguments against it this time will be:
 No one wants a separate Goa.
 The current generation know nothing else but being part of India.
 Goa will lose out on India's economic boom.
 
 To this I have the following answer. 
 Then why not let the people confirm this while giving yourself a chance to 
 regain the high moral ground.
 
 Are you afraid of the will of the people of Goa?
 
 Roland.
 
 Sent from my iPhone
 


[Goanet] A Goa Referendum

2014-09-13 Thread Roland Francis
Sorry my previous message was sent in error uncompleted.

India needs to correct a historical wrong committed in 1961, by asking the Goan 
people to determine their own destiny even if it is 53 years later. Goa was not 
of the Portuguese to give nor of the Indians to take. 

To accept the political and geographical reality, the referendum  should be on 
the following question:

Should Goa determine its own independent economic future subject to India's 
defence and foreign affairs control allowing it to enforce its own borders and 
laws separate from the Indian constitution.
Yes or no.

The arguments against it this time will be:
No one wants a separate Goa.
The current generation know nothing else but being part of India.
Goa will lose out on India's economic boom.

To this I have the following answer. 
Then why not let the people confirm this while giving yourself a chance to 
regain the high moral ground.

Are you afraid of the will of the people of Goa?

Roland.

Sent from my iPhone